How many possible ways can ,
and each be assigned a different
number from the list , ,
so that the value of
is odd?
Problem 237
Pick one
Official solution
Solution 1:
We assign each of , and a different number from the list , , , and then determine the value of for each possibility.
If , and , then , which is
odd.
If , and , then , which is
odd.
If , and , then , which is
odd.
If , and , then , which is
odd.
If , and , then , which is
odd.
If , and , then , which is
odd.
We have considered all possible ways to assign the values ,
and , and so there are such ways for which is odd.
Solution 2:
First, recognize that both and
are odd, and is even.
When each of , and is assigned a different number from the
list , , , then either and are both odd, or exactly one of and is odd.
If and are both odd, then is odd and , and so is odd.
If exactly one of and is odd, then is even and is odd, and so is odd.
Thus, the value of is
always odd.
When assigning the values , , , there are choices for the value of , followed by choices for the value of , and then choice for the value of .
Since is odd for all
such choices, then there are such ways to assign the
numbers.