Olympiad Maths Prep

Track / Stage 8 / 174 of 180 #1874 of 2000

Problem 1874

IMO Shortlist mid-range; USAMO P2/P5
Geometry Difficulty 8.9 Prove it USA IMO TST · United States

Let ABCABC be a triangle and let MM and NN denote the midpoints of AB\overline{AB} and AC\overline{AC}, respectively. Let XX be a point such that AX\overline{AX} is tangent to the circumcircle of triangle ABCABC. Denote by ωB\omega_B the circle through MM and BB tangent to MX\overline{MX}, and by ωC\omega_C the circle through NN and CC tangent to NX\overline{NX}. Show that ωB\omega_B and ωC\omega_C intersect on line BCBC.

This one wants a proof. Work it on paper, read the official solution, then mark yourself honestly — the ladder only means something if the record is true.

Official solution

First solution using symmedians (Merlijn Staps) Let XY\overline{XY} be the other tangent from XX to (AMN)(AMN).
Claim. Line XM\overline{XM} is tangent to (BMY)(BMY); hence YY lies on ωB\omega_B.
Figure 1
*Proof.* Let ZZ be the midpoint of AY\overline{AY}. Then MX\overline{MX} is the MM-symmedian in triangle AMYAMY. Since MZBY\overline{MZ} \parallel \overline{BY}, it follows that AMX=ZMY=BYM\angle AMX = \angle ZMY = \angle BYM. We conclude that XM\overline{XM} is tangent to the circumcircle of triangle BMYBMY. \square

Similarly, ωC\omega_C is the circumcircle of triangle CNYCNY. As AMYNAMYN is cyclic too, it follows that ωB\omega_B and ωC\omega_C intersect on BC\overline{BC}, by Miquel's theorem.

Second solution (Jetze Zoethout) Let ωB\omega_B intersect BC\overline{BC} again at SS and let MS\overline{MS} intersect AC\overline{AC} again at YY. Angle chasing gives XMY=XMS=MBS=ABC=XAC=XAY\angle XMY = \angle XMS = \angle MBS = \angle ABC = \angle XAC = \angle XAY, so YY is on the circumcircle of triangle AMXAMX. Furthermore, from XMY=ABC\angle XMY = \angle ABC and ACB=XAB=XYM\angle ACB = \angle XAB = \angle XYM it follows that ABCXMY\triangle ABC \sim \triangle XMY and from XAY=MBS\angle XAY = \angle MBS and YXA=YMA=BMS\angle YXA = \angle YMA = \angle BMS it follows that AXYBMS\triangle AXY \sim \triangle BMS.
---
Figure 2
We now find
ANAX=AN/BMAX/BM=AC/ABMS/XY=AB/ABMS/XM=XMMS, \frac{AN}{AX} = \frac{AN/BM}{AX/BM} = \frac{AC/AB}{MS/XY} = \frac{AB/AB}{MS/XM} = \frac{XM}{MS},
which together with XMS=XAN\angle XMS = \angle XAN yields XMSXAN\triangle XMS \sim \triangle XAN. From XSY=XSM=XNA=XNY\angle XSY = \angle XSM = \angle XNA = \angle XNY we now have that SS is on the circumcircle of triangle XNYXNY. Finally, we have XNS=XYS=XYM=ACB=NCS\angle XNS = \angle XYS = \angle XYM = \angle ACB = \angle NCS so XN\overline{XN} is tangent to the circle through C,NC, N, and SS, as desired.

Third solution by moving points method Fix triangle ABCABC and animate XX along the tangent at AA. We let DD denote the second intersection point of ωC\omega_C with line BC\overline{BC}.
Claim. The composed map XDX \mapsto D is a fractional linear transformation (i.e. a projective map) in terms of a real coordinate on line AA,BC\overline{AA}, \overline{BC}.
*Proof*. Let \ell denote the perpendicular bisector of CN\overline{CN}, also equipped with a real coordinate. We let PP denote the intersection of XM\overline{XM} with \ell, SS the circumcenter of CMD\triangle CMD. Let TT denote the midpoint of BD\overline{BD}.
We claim that the composed map
AABCBC \overline{AA} \rightarrow \ell \rightarrow \ell \rightarrow \overline{BC} \rightarrow \overline{BC}
by XPSTDX \mapsto P \mapsto S \mapsto T \mapsto D
is projective, by showing each individual map is projective.
Figure 3
* The map XPX \mapsto P is projective since it is a perspectivity through NN from AA\overline{AA} to \ell.
* The map PSP \mapsto S is projective since it is equivalent to a negative inversion on \ell at the midpoint of NC\overline{NC} with radius 12NC\frac{1}{2}NC. (Note PNS=90\angle PNS = 90^\circ is fixed.)
* The map STS \mapsto T is projective since it is a perspectivity BC\ell \to \overline{BC} through the point at infinity perpendicular to BC\overline{BC} (in fact, it is linear).
* The map TDT \mapsto D is projective (in fact, linear) since it is a homothety through CC with fixed ratio 2.
Thus the composed map is projective as well. \square

Similarly, if we define DD' so that XM\overline{XM} is tangent to (BMD)(BMD'), the map XDX \mapsto D' is projective as well. We aim to show D=DD = D', and since the maps correspond to fractional linear transformations in projective coordinates, it suffices to verify it for three distinct choices of XX. We do so:
* If X=AAMNX = \overline{AA} \cap \overline{MN}, then DD and DD' satisfy MB=MDMB = MD', NC=NDNC = ND. This means they are the feet of the AA-altitude on BC\overline{BC}.
* As XX approaches AA the points DD and DD' approach the infinity point along BC\overline{BC}.
* If XX is a point at infinity along AA\overline{AA}, then DD and DD' coincide with the midpoint of BC\overline{BC}.
This completes the solution.

Fourth solution by isogonal conjugates (Anant Mudgal) Let YY be the isogonal conjugate of XX in AMN\triangle AMN and ZZ be the reflection of YY in MN\overline{MN}. As AX\overline{AX} is tangent to the circumcircle of AMN\triangle AMN, it follows that AYMN\overline{AY} \parallel \overline{MN}. Thus ZZ lies on BC\overline{BC} since MN\overline{MN} bisects the strip made by AY\overline{AY} and BC\overline{BC}.
Figure 4
Finally,
ZMX=ZMN+NMX=NMY+YMA=NMA=ZBM \angle ZMX = \angle ZMN + \angle NMX = \angle NMY + \angle YMA = \angle NMA = \angle ZBM
so XM\overline{XM} is tangent to the circumcircle of ZMB\triangle ZMB, hence ZZ lies on ωB\omega_B. Similarly, ZZ lies on ωC\omega_C and we're done.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic, difficulty and ordering added by this site.