Maths Olympiad Prep

Track / Stage 6 / 225 of 400 #1705 of 2444

Problem 1705

National Olympiad, first round
Number theory Difficulty 6.4 Prove it Canadian Mathematical Olympiad · Canada

Let TT be the set of all positive integer divisors of 20041002004^{100}. What is the largest possible number of elements that a subset SS of TT can have if no element of SS is an integer multiple of any other element of SS ?

This one wants a proof. Work it on paper, then read the official solution and mark yourself. Be honest about it: the record is only any use to you if it is.

Next problem →

Official solution

Solution:
Assume throughout that a,b,ca, b, c are nonnegative integers. Since the prime factorization of 20042004 is 2004=2231672004 = 2^{2} \cdot 3 \cdot 167,
T={2a3b167c0a200,0b,c100} T = \left\{ 2^{a} 3^{b} 167^{c} \mid 0 \leq a \leq 200, 0 \leq b, c \leq 100 \right\}
Let
S={2200bc3b167c0b,c100} S = \left\{ 2^{200-b-c} 3^{b} 167^{c} \mid 0 \leq b, c \leq 100 \right\}
For any 0b,c1000 \leq b, c \leq 100, we have 0200bc2000 \leq 200-b-c \leq 200, so SS is a subset of TT. Since there are 101101 possible values for bb and 101101 possible values for cc, SS contains 1012101^{2} elements. We will show that no element of SS is a multiple of another and that no larger subset of TT satisfies this condition.

Suppose 2200bc3b167c2^{200-b-c} 3^{b} 167^{c} is an integer multiple of 2200jk3j167k2^{200-j-k} 3^{j} 167^{k}. Then
200bc200jk,bj,ck 200-b-c \geq 200-j-k, \quad b \geq j, \quad c \geq k
But this first inequality implies b+cj+kb+c \leq j+k, which together with bj,ckb \geq j, c \geq k gives b=jb = j and c=kc = k. Hence no element of SS is an integer multiple of another element of SS.

Let UU be a subset of TT with more than 1012101^{2} elements. Since there are only 1012101^{2} distinct pairs (b,c)(b, c) with 0b,c1000 \leq b, c \leq 100, then (by the pigeonhole principle) UU must contain two elements u1=2a13b1167c1u_{1} = 2^{a_{1}} 3^{b_{1}} 167^{c_{1}} and u2=2a23b2167c2u_{2} = 2^{a_{2}} 3^{b_{2}} 167^{c_{2}}, with b1=b2b_{1} = b_{2} and c1=c2c_{1} = c_{2}, but a1a2a_{1} \neq a_{2}. If a1>a2a_{1} > a_{2}, then u1u_{1} is a multiple of u2u_{2} and if a1<a2a_{1} < a_{2}, then u2u_{2} is a multiple of u1u_{1}. Hence UU does not satisfy the desired condition.

Therefore the largest possible number of elements that such a subset of TT can have is 1012=10201101^{2} = 10201.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty, ordering) added by this project.