Let be the set of all positive integer divisors of . What is the largest possible number of elements that a subset of can have if no element of is an integer multiple of any other element of ?
Problem 1705
Official solution
Solution:
Assume throughout that are nonnegative integers. Since the prime factorization of is ,
Let
For any , we have , so is a subset of . Since there are possible values for and possible values for , contains elements. We will show that no element of is a multiple of another and that no larger subset of satisfies this condition.
Suppose is an integer multiple of . Then
But this first inequality implies , which together with gives and . Hence no element of is an integer multiple of another element of .
Let be a subset of with more than elements. Since there are only distinct pairs with , then (by the pigeonhole principle) must contain two elements and , with and , but . If , then is a multiple of and if , then is a multiple of . Hence does not satisfy the desired condition.
Therefore the largest possible number of elements that such a subset of can have is .