Let be a non-constant function from the set of positive integers into the set of positive integers, such that divides for all distinct positive integers . Prove that there exist infinitely many primes such that divides for some positive integer .
Problem 1781
Official solutions — 2
Solution 1
Assume that there are only finitely many primes that divide some function value produced of .
There are infinitely many positive integers such that for all , e.g. with sufficiently large. Pick any such . The condition of the problem then yields . Assume . Then we must have for at least one . This yields . But this contradicts the fact that .
Hence we must have for all such .
Now, for any positive integer and all such , we have , i.e., . Since this is true for infinitely many positive integers we must have . Hence is a constant function, a contradiction. Therefore, our initial assumption was false and there are indeed infinitely many primes dividing for some positive integer .
Solution 2
Assume that there are only finitely many primes that divide some function value of . Since is not identically , we must have .
Then there exist non-negative integers such that
We can pick a positive integer such that . Let
Then for all we have that divides and hence by the condition of the problem also . This implies that is divisible by but not by for all and therefore .
Hence
But since divides this can only be true if , which contradicts the choice of .