Annalisa, Bruna and Cecilia play football: one of them is in goal and the other two are on the field. Whoever scores a goal stays on the field, while whoever has not scored swaps with the goalkeeper. Knowing that Annalisa has been on the field for 12 turns and Bruna for 21 turns, while Cecilia has been in goal 8 times, who started in goal?
Problem 811
Pick one
Official solution
Solution:
The answer is (A). Let be the number of turns in which, respectively, Annalisa, Bruna and Cecilia are in goal, while are the number of turns in which they are on the field. If is the total number of turns played, then we will have , , and , , . At each turn, one of increases by one, while two of increase by one, so and substituting the previously found values gives . Since , there is only one way in which Annalisa could have played, namely if she starts in goal and returns there every two turns, thus never scoring a goal.