Prove that for any positive integer , there exists an arithmetic sequence
of rational numbers, where are relatively prime positive integers for each , such that the positive integers are all distinct.
Problem 2096
Official solutions — 2
Solution 1
For , there is nothing to prove. Henceforth assume .
Let be distinct primes such that
and let . By Chinese Remainder Theorem, there exists a positive integer satisfying
for all and . Consider the following sequence:
This sequence is obviously an arithmetic sequence of positive rational numbers of length . For each , the numerator is divisible by but not by for , for otherwise divides , which is not possible because . Let
Then
and all 's are distinct from each other. Moreover, implies
and hence all 's are distinct from 's. It only remains to show that all 's are distinct from each other. This follows from
by our choice of . Thus, the arithmetic sequence
of positive rational numbers satisfies the conditions of the problem.
Solution 2
For any positive integer , consider the sequence
Note that for all . So, taking
we have and
for any . Therefore this sequence satisfies every condition given in the problem.