Let be natural numbers such that being two given positive integers.
Prove that is not a prime number.
Prove that if is maximum, then divides .
Problem 1637
Official solution
Let's break down the problem into two parts and provide a detailed solution for each.
### Part (a): Prove that is not a prime number.
1. Given: where are positive integers.
2. Observation: Since are natural numbers, is a natural number.
3. Sum of Cubes: We know that .
4. Given Condition: .
5. Evenness: Since is even, must also be even.
6. Prime Check: The smallest even prime number is 2. For to be 2, we would need . However, this is impossible because are natural numbers and the smallest sum of cubes of natural numbers is .
7. Conclusion: Since is even and greater than 2, cannot be a prime number.
### Part (b): Prove that if is maximum, then divides .
1. Given: .
2. Divisibility by 3: Notice that is divisible by 3 because if , then . Hence, is divisible by 3.
3. AM-GM Inequality: To maximize , by the Arithmetic Mean-Geometric Mean Inequality (AM-GM), .
4. **Expression for **: Let .
5. **Expression for **:
6. Divisibility by 64: If at least one of or is even, is visibly divisible by . If both are odd, has an extra factor of to complete the factor of .
7. Divisibility by 31: If at least one of or is divisible by 31, so is . If not, and by Fermat's Little Theorem, , so . Thus, is divisible by 31.
8. Conclusion: Combining these, is divisible by .
The final answer is is divisible by .