1. Initial Setup:
Let n and m be integers greater than 1, and let a1,a2,…,am be positive integers not greater than nm. We need to prove that there exist positive integers b1,b2,…,bm not greater than n such that
gcd(a1+b1,a2+b2,…,am+bm)<n.
2. Vector Definition:
Since bi∈{1,2,…,n}, we have nm vectors (b1,b2,…,bm). Label them as vi where i ranges from 1 to nm. The ordering of the i-s does not matter.
3. GCD Definition:
Define
lvi:=gcd(a1+b1,…,am+bm)
where vi is the vector associated with (b1,…,bm).
4. Claim 1:
If ai=aj for any i<j, then the problem condition holds true.
- Proof:
If ai=aj, consider vectors vx=(b1,…,bi,…,bj,…,bm) and vy=(b1,…,bi+1,…,bj,…,bm). Note that p∣u and p∣u+1 cannot both hold true for any prime p. Therefore, at least one of lvx or lvy equals 1. Since n>1, we are done here. ■
5. Assumption for Contradiction:
Assume on the contrary that lvi≥n for all the nm vectors vi.
6. Claim 2:
We cannot have lvi=lvj for any i=j, i.e., all the lvi are distinct numbers.
- Proof:
Assume on the contrary that i=j and lvi=lvj. Since i=j, at least one of the bi-s is different for both, say bi∈vi and bi′∈vj with bi=bi′. Then
lvi∣(ai+bi)andlvi∣(ai+bi′)⟹lvi∣(bi−bi′)⟹n≤lvi≤∣bi−bi′∣
which is a contradiction as 1≤bi,bi′≤n. ■
7. **Range of lvi:**
Note that
n≤lvi≤1≤i≤nmax{ai+bi}≤nm+n
for all 1≤i≤nm.
8. Maximum Value Case:
If lvi=nm+n for some vi, then we must have vi=(n,n,…,n) (i.e., b1=⋯=bm=n) and a1=a2=⋯=am=nm. Since m≥2, we have at least two equal numbers a1,a2, leading to a contradiction by Claim 1.
9. Distinct Values:
Thus,
{lv1,lv2,…,lvnm}≡{n,n+1,…,nm+n−1}
i.e., the two sets are equal. Hence lvi=nm+n−1 for some i.
10. **Contradiction for m≥3:**
If m≥3, then we will find two equal numbers among {a1,a2,a3}, leading to a contradiction by Claim 1.
11. **Case m=2:**
For m=2, we must have {a1,a2}≡{n2,n2−1}. Suppose a1=n2 and a2=n2−1. Then choose b1=b2=n. Hence
gcd(a1+b1,a2+b2)=gcd(n2+n,n2+n−1)=1<n,
a contradiction.
12. Conclusion:
Hence, we will find a vi with lvi<n, as desired. ■