For a non-empty set denote by the product of all elements of . Does there exist a set of elements such that for any one has that is an odd integer? Consider two cases:
1) All elements of are irrational numbers.
2) At least one element of is a rational number.
Problem 1256
Official solution
### Case 1: All elements of are irrational numbers
1. **Assume the form of the set **:
Since is an odd integer for any , we can infer that the difference between any two elements of must be an even integer. Therefore, we assume the set is of the form:
where is an irrational number.
2. Existence of a root:
Consider the polynomial equation formed by the product of the elements of :
Since the degree of the polynomial on the left-hand side is odd (2021), it must have at least one real root. By the Rational Root Theorem, if this root were rational, it would have to be . However, due to the size and nature of the polynomial, it is clear that cannot be roots. Therefore, there exists an irrational root .
3. Conclusion for irrational numbers:
The set satisfies the condition that is an odd integer for any .
### Case 2: At least one element of is a rational number
1. **Assume the form of the set **:
By the same logic as before, the elements of must differ by an even integer. Therefore, we assume the set is of the form:
where is a rational number.
2. Valuation argument:
Let be a rational number in lowest terms. Consider the -adic valuation . If , then:
However, for to be an odd integer, must also be . This implies , meaning the rational numbers have no denominator and are integers.
3. Modulo 2 argument:
Since the elements are integers differing by an even amount, consider the product modulo 2. If all elements are odd, then:
and:
If all elements are even, then:
and:
In both cases, cannot be an odd integer, leading to a contradiction.
4. Conclusion for rational numbers:
It is impossible to have at least one rational number in the set while satisfying the given condition.