We have a closed path on a vertices of a × square which pass from each vertice exactly once . prove that we have two adjacent vertices such that if we cut the path from these points then length of each pieces is not less than quarter of total path .
Problem 1550
Official solution
1. Initial Setup and Assumptions:
- We are given a closed path on the vertices of an square, passing through each vertex exactly once.
- We need to prove that there exist two adjacent vertices such that if we cut the path at these points, each resulting piece has a length of at least a quarter of the total path.
2. **Observation on **:
- It is noted that must be even for such a path to exist. Hence, we write for some integer .
3. Graph Representation:
- The closed path divides the area of the square into two parts: inside and outside.
- Consider each square inside the path as a vertex of a graph. Connect two vertices if their corresponding squares are adjacent.
- This graph is a tree (connected and acyclic).
4. Vertices Count Using Pick's Theorem:
- By Pick's Theorem, the number of vertices inside the path is .
5. Maximum Degree of the Tree:
- The maximum degree of this tree is 4, as each square can be adjacent to at most 4 other squares.
6. Lemma: If the maximum degree of a tree is 4, then there is an edge in it that divides the graph into two parts, each having at least vertices.
- Proof of Lemma:
- Let be an arbitrary vertex and make it the root of the tree.
- Let its neighbors be .
- Let the subgraph of our tree with the root be .
- By the pigeonhole principle, one of the 's has at least vertices, say .
- If the edge is not good, must have at least vertices except .
- Repeat the process for the subgraphs with roots as neighbors of .
- This process must stop eventually, yielding a good edge, as otherwise, we would get a graph with infinite vertices.
7. Application of Lemma to the Main Problem:
- There exists an edge dividing the graph into two parts, each having at least vertices.
- This edge cuts the lattice edge between two vertices, say and .
8. Conclusion:
- Deleting the edge results in two trees, each having at least vertices.
- Using Pick's Theorem, each of the two paths connecting and has at least edges.
- Thus, each piece of the path has a length of at least a quarter of the total path.