Maths Olympiad Prep

Track / Stage 8 / 67 of 180 #1767 of 1964

Problem 1767

IMO Shortlist mid-range; USAMO P2/P5
Combinatorics Difficulty 8.2 Prove it

Let n>1n>1 be a given integer. Let GG be a finite simple graph with the property that each of its edges is contained in at most nn cycles. Prove that the chromatic number of the graph is at most n+1n+1.

This one wants a proof. Work it on paper, then read the official solution and mark yourself. Be honest about it: the record is only any use to you if it is.

Official solution

1. Definitions and Initial Setup:
- Let G G be a finite simple graph with the property that each of its edges is contained in at most n n cycles.
- We need to prove that the chromatic number of G G is at most n+1 n+1 .

2. Claim 1:
- Statement: G G has a χ\chi-critical (n+2)(n+2)-chromatic subgraph H H with V(H)=V(G) V(H) = V(G) .
- Proof:
- There exists a subgraph G0 G_0 of G G with χ(G0)=n+2\chi(G_0) = n+2 .
- If G0 G_0 is χ\chi-critical, the claim is trivial.
- If not, there exists an edge eE(G0) e \in E(G_0) such that χ(G0e)=n+2\chi(G_0 - e) = n+2 .
- Repeat this process until obtaining a χ\chi-critical (n+2)(n+2)-chromatic subgraph H H of G G . This process terminates because G G is finite. \blacksquare

3. Claim 2:
- Statement: Let H H be the χ\chi-critical (n+2)(n+2)-chromatic graph. Then every pair of adjacent vertices can be connected by n n edge-disjoint even paths.
- Proof:
- Let (x,y)E(H)(x, y) \in E(H). Since H H is χ\chi-critical, H(x,y) H - (x, y) has a coloring γ\gamma with n+1 n+1 colors: 1,2,,n+1 1, 2, \ldots, n+1 .
- Since H H is not (n+1)(n+1)-colorable, assume without loss of generality that γ(x)=γ(y)=1\gamma(x) = \gamma(y) = 1.
- Consider another color jS:={2,,n+1} j \in S := \{2, \ldots, n+1\} and the graph Hj H_j induced by the vertices of colors 1 1 and j j .
- Let Hj H_j' be the connected component of Hj H_j containing x x . If yV(Hj) y \notin V(H_j') , we can switch the colors 1 1 and j j in V(Hj) V(H_j') , resulting in a (n+1)(n+1)-coloring of H H , a contradiction.
- Hence, yV(Hj) y \in V(H_j') . Since Hj H_j' is connected, there exists a path Pj P_j from x x to y y in Hj H_j' .
- Each edge of Pj P_j connects a vertex of color 1 1 to a vertex of color j j , making Pj P_j an even-length path.
- The paths P2,,Pn+1 P_2, \ldots, P_{n+1} must be edge-disjoint. This proves the claim. \blacksquare

4. Claim 3:
- Statement: The graph H H (from Claim 1) contains an even cycle.
- Proof:
- Let (a,b)E(H)(a, b) \in E(H). From n2 n \geq 2 and Claim 2, there are two edge-disjoint even paths P P and Q Q from a a to b b , forming the circuit C=PQ\mathcal{C} = P \cup Q.
- If C\mathcal{C} is a cycle, we are done.
- Otherwise, let M:=(V(P)V(Q)){a,b} M := (V(P) \cap V(Q)) \setminus \{a, b\} \neq \varnothing . Let vM v \in M be the vertex closest to a a on P P .
- Define P P' as the path from a a to v v in P P and P P'' as the path from v v to b b in P P . Similarly, define Q Q' and Q Q'' .
- The cycle C=PQ\mathcal{C}' = P' \cup Q' intersects the circuit PQ P'' \cup Q'' only at v v .
- If C\mathcal{C}' is even, we are done. If C\mathcal{C}' is odd, then 1C=P+Q 1 \equiv |\mathcal{C}'| = |P'| + |Q'| , implying P≢Q |P'| \not\equiv |Q'| .
- Since P0 |P| \equiv 0 , it follows that QP=Q+P≢P+P=P0 |Q' \cup P''| = |Q'| + |P''| \not\equiv |P'| + |P''| = |P| \equiv 0 , implying that the cycle formed by QP Q' \cup P'' and the edge (a,b)(a, b) is even. \blacksquare

5. Final Argument:
- Using Claim 3, consider an even cycle C\mathcal{C} in H H and (x,y)E(C)(x, y) \in E(\mathcal{C}).
- From Claim 2, there are n n edge-disjoint even paths Q1,,Qn Q_1, \ldots, Q_n from x x to y y in H H .
- The cycles Ck=(V(Qk),E(Qk)(x,y))\mathcal{C}_k = (V(Q_k), E(Q_k) \cup (x, y)) are of odd lengths for k=1,,n k = 1, \ldots, n , implying at least n+1 n+1 cycles in G G passing through the edge (x,y)(x, y), contradicting the given condition that each edge is contained in at most n n cycles.

The final answer is χ(G)n+1 \boxed{ \chi(G) \leq n+1 } .

Source: NuminaMath-1.5, licensed Apache-2.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic, difficulty and ordering added by this site.