Let be a function, and define by . If is a two-variable polynomial in and , prove that it must be constant.
Problem 1576
Official solution
1. **Fix and consider :**
- Since is defined as the greatest common divisor of and , it must be a positive integer that divides .
- Therefore, for all .
2. Bounded polynomial argument:
- Since for all , is bounded above by .
- A polynomial in that is bounded for all must be constant. This is because a non-constant polynomial in would grow without bound as increases or decreases.
3. **Conclusion for fixed :**
- Since is a polynomial in and is bounded, it must be constant for fixed .
- Let this constant be . Thus, for all .
4. **Symmetry and polynomial in :**
- By the definition of , we have . Therefore, .
- This implies that does not actually depend on and is a constant value for all and .
5. Final conclusion:
- Since is constant for all and , it follows that is a constant polynomial.