Maths Olympiad Prep

Track / Stage 6 / 237 of 400 #1237 of 1964

Problem 1237

National olympiad, first round
Geometry Difficulty 6.3 Prove it

Let the centroid of the face opposite to the vertices A,B,C,DA, B, C, D of a tetrahedron be denoted by SAS_{A}, SBS_{B}, SCS_{C}, SDS_{D}, respectively. Prove that if we consider the tetrahedron to be made of homogeneous thin plates for its faces and its interior to be empty, then the center of mass of this system coincides with the center of the sphere inscribed in the tetrahedron SASBSCSDS_{A} S_{B} S_{C} S_{D}.

(This problem is related to Dr. E. Schröder's article titled "Determination of the Center of Mass of a Triangle Line." See Volume 53, Issue 5.)

This one wants a proof. Work it on paper, then read the official solution and mark yourself. Be honest about it: the record is only any use to you if it is.

Official solution

A homogeneous BCDB C D triangular plate's geometric center SAS_{A} is also the point of application of the resultant force of the elementary gravitational forces acting on it in a dynamic sense. Therefore, we can think of concentrating the plate's mass mA=k1tAm_{A}=k_{1} t_{A} at SAS_{A}, where tAt_{A} is the area of the plate, and the proportionality factor k1k_{1} represents the "surface density" of the material. Continuing this, it is sufficient to determine the center of mass of a system of four points SXS_{X}, each with mass tXt_{X}, where X=A,B,C,DX=A, B, C, D, since in the absence of further information, k1k_{1} can be assumed to be the same for all four plates.

!

Further, let's combine the masses of two points. The common center of mass of the pair of masses at SXS_{X} and SYS_{Y} (where YXY \neq X) is at the point SXYS_{X Y} on the segment SXSYS_{X} S_{Y} such that (by the equality of moments) SXYSX:SXYSY=mY:mX=tY:tXS_{X Y} S_{X}: S_{X Y} S_{Y}=m_{Y}: m_{X}=t_{Y}: t_{X}, or, with suitable proportionality factors k2k_{2} and k3k_{3}, SXYSX=k2mYk3tYS_{X Y} S_{X}=k_{2} m_{Y}-k_{3} t_{Y}. Using the same principle, we can find the desired center of mass GG on the segment SABSCDS_{A B} S_{C D} by choosing XX and YY as AA and BB in one pair of masses.

Furthermore, we use the fact that all four segments XSXX S_{X} pass through the centroid SS of the tetrahedron ABCDA B C D such that SX=3SSXS X=3 \cdot S S_{X}, so the tetrahedron SASBSCSDS_{A} S_{B} S_{C} S_{D} is obtained from the previous one by a central similarity. (The value of the ratio is 1/3-1 / 3, but this is not significant.) This implies that the ratio of the areas of any two faces of the new tetrahedron is the same as the ratio of the corresponding original faces tt, for example (briefly, symbolically):

(SASBSC):(SASBSD)=(ABC):(ABD)=tD:tC \left(S_{A} S_{B} S_{C}\right):\left(S_{A} S_{B} S_{D}\right)=(A B C):(A B D)=t_{D}: t_{C}

Now, let's project the new tetrahedron onto a plane perpendicular to the edge SASBS_{A} S_{B} - in other words, look at it from infinitely far away in this direction - and denote the projections (as apparent images) of the points in the same way as the points themselves. We only see the triangle SASCSDS_{A} S_{C} S_{D}, and consider the ratio of the two sides starting from SAS_{A} in this triangle. The lengths of SASCS_{A} S_{C} and SASDS_{A} S_{D} are the actual lengths of the altitudes of the triangles SASBSCS_{A} S_{B} S_{C} and SASBSDS_{A} S_{B} S_{D}, respectively, which are perpendicular to their common side SASBS_{A} S_{B}. Therefore, their ratio is the same as the ratio of the areas of these two triangles, which, according to the previous example, is tD:tCt_{D}: t_{C}, and finally SASC=k4tD,SASD=k4tCS_{A} S_{C}=k_{4} t_{D}, S_{A} S_{D}=k_{4} t_{C}, where k4k_{4} is a suitable proportionality factor.

From the ratio pair SCDSC:SCDSD=SASC:SASDS_{C D} S_{C}: S_{C D} S_{D}=S_{A} S_{C}: S_{A} S_{D}, it follows that SCDS_{C D} lies on the angle bisector starting from SAS_{A} in the apparent triangle, and that we also see the desired GG on this bisector. However, our lines are the images of planes perpendicular to the plane of the diagram, so GG lies on the plane that bisects the dihedral angle between the faces SASBSCS_{A} S_{B} S_{C} and SASBSDS_{A} S_{B} S_{D} of the new tetrahedron; thus, the distances of GG from these two face planes are equal; with appropriate notation, rD=rCr_{D}=r_{C}.

We apply our result by choosing the first pair of points SXS_{X} as AA and CC, and then as BB and CC, so rD=rBr_{D}=r_{B}, and then rA=rDr_{A}=r_{D}, so GG is equidistant from all four faces of the tetrahedron SXS_{X}. This proves the statement of the problem.

Remarks. 1. The proven statement, without using the centers of mass of the faces, also means that if we place a mass proportional to the area of the opposite face at each vertex of the tetrahedron, the center of mass of the system gives the center of the inscribed sphere of the tetrahedron.

2. A similar center of mass interpretation can be obtained for the centers of the incircles (external tangent circles) of a triangle and the centers of the tangent spheres of a tetrahedron - if we assign a negative mass to one of the sides of the triangle (a repulsive force instead of an attractive force). In the case of a tetrahedron, a total of 8 tangent spheres are possible, as we can assign a negative mass to two faces at the same time, but for example, in the case of a regular tetrahedron, only 5 are created.
3. The proofs can also be carried out using vectors.

Source: NuminaMath-1.5, licensed Apache-2.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic, difficulty and ordering added by this site.