1. Define the Partial Sums:
Let {s1,s2,…,s2n} be the set of all partial sums of the natural numbers x1,x2,…,xn. By the problem's condition, all these partial sums are distinct. We can order them such that s1≤s2≤⋯≤s2n.
2. Condition on Differences:
Since all partial sums are distinct, for any 1≤k,l≤2n, we have sk−sl≥∣k−l∣.
3. Sum of Partial Sums:
The sum of all partial sums is given by:
k=1∑2nsk=2n−1i=1∑nxi
This is because each xi appears in exactly half of the subsets of {x1,x2,…,xn}.
4. Sum of Squares of Partial Sums:
The sum of the squares of all partial sums is:
k=1∑2nsk2=2n−1i=1∑nxi2+2n−11≤i<j≤n∑xixj
This follows from the fact that each xi2 appears in the square of each subset sum where xi is included, and each xixj appears in the product of each pair of subset sums where both xi and xj are included.
5. **Expression for ∑i=1nxi2:**
Using the above results, we can express ∑i=1nxi2 as:
i=1∑nxi2=2⋅2n−1∑k=12nsk2−(2n−1∑k=12nsk)2
6. Simplifying the Expression:
Simplifying further, we get:
22n−1i=1∑nxi2=2nk=1∑2nsk2−(k=1∑2nsk)2
This can be rewritten using the identity for the sum of squared differences:
22n−1i=1∑nxi2=21k,l=1∑2n(sk−sl)2
7. Lower Bound on Sum of Squared Differences:
Given sk−sl≥∣k−l∣, we have:
k,l=1∑2n(sk−sl)2≥k,l=1∑2n(k−l)2
The sum of squared differences for integers k and l from 1 to 2n is:
k,l=1∑2n(k−l)2=2nk=1∑2nk2−(k=1∑2nk)2
8. Calculating the Sums:
Using the formulas for the sum of the first m natural numbers and the sum of their squares:
k=1∑2nk=22n(2n+1)=2n−1(2n+1)
k=1∑2nk2=62n(2n+1)(2n+1+1)
9. Substituting Back:
Substituting these into the inequality, we get:
2nk=1∑2nk2−(k=1∑2nk)2=2n⋅62n(2n+1)(2n+1+1)−(2n−1(2n+1))2
Simplifying this expression, we find:
2n⋅62n(2n+1)(2n+1+1)−22n−2(2n+1)2=22n−1⋅34n−1
10. Final Inequality:
Therefore, we have:
22n−1i=1∑nxi2≥22n−1⋅34n−1
Dividing both sides by 22n−1, we get:
i=1∑nxi2≥34n−1
The final answer is i=1∑nxi2≥34n−1