Suppose that is the number of ways to express as a sum of some naturall numbers (the two representations and are considered the same). Prove that for an infinite number of 's is even and for an infinite number of 's is odd.
Problem 1396
Official solution
1. Define the partition function and generating functions:
Let be the number of ways to express as a sum of natural numbers, where the order of summands does not matter. The generating function for is given by:
2. Express the generating function for partitions into distinct parts:
Let be the number of ways to express as a sum of distinct positive integers. The generating function for is:
Using the identity for the product of sums:
3. Express the generating function for partitions into odd parts:
Let be the number of ways to express as a sum of odd positive integers. The generating function for is:
4. Equate the generating functions:
By the Pentagonal Number Theorem, we have:
This identity helps in understanding the parity of .
5. Kolberg's result:
Kolberg's result states that for an infinite number of , is even, and for an infinite number of , is odd. This is based on the identities:
and
6. Conclusion:
The parity of is a complex problem, but Kolberg's proof shows that there are infinitely many for which is even and infinitely many for which is odd.