Given distinct positive integer . For , is the smallest number different from which doesn't divide . Proof that every number large enough appears in the sequence.
Problem 1879
Official solution
Given distinct positive integers . For , is defined as the smallest number different from which does not divide . We aim to prove that every sufficiently large number appears in the sequence.
### Proof:
Claim: For sufficiently large , the least common multiple (LCM) of a set of natural numbers satisfies .
This claim is intuitive and can be shown through detailed analysis, which is omitted here for brevity.
Claim: The ratio is bounded by a constant.
Proof:
Assume, for contradiction, that is not bounded. Define a number as "good" if for all . Pick a sufficiently large good such that .
Let . Since , by our earlier claim, . Since , there exists an element in smaller than that does not divide . This contradicts the definition of , as that element would have been chosen instead of . Therefore, must be bounded by some constant .
Now, assume for contradiction that there exists a sufficiently large number that does not appear in the sequence. Let have a sufficiently large prime power factor, say . For all , since , . This implies divides one of the terms . If is divisible by , call "friendly".
For some , since at least numbers in are friendly, one of the numbers is at least . This contradicts the claim that is bounded by .
Therefore, every sufficiently large number must appear in the sequence.
The answer is: \boxed{\text{Every sufficiently large number appears in the sequence}}.