Olympiad Maths Prep

Track / Stage 8 / 179 of 180 #1879 of 2000

Problem 1879

IMO Shortlist mid-range; USAMO P2/P5
Number theory Difficulty 9.0 Find the answer china_team_selection_test

Given distinct positive integer a1,a2,,a2020 a_1,a_2,…,a_{2020} . For n2021 n \ge 2021 , ana_n is the smallest number different from a1,a2,,an1a_1,a_2,…,a_{n-1} which doesn't divide an2020...an2an1a_{n-2020}...a_{n-2}a_{n-1}. Proof that every number large enough appears in the sequence.

Official solution

Given distinct positive integers a1,a2,,a2020 a_1, a_2, \ldots, a_{2020} . For n2021 n \ge 2021 , an a_n is defined as the smallest number different from a1,a2,,an1 a_1, a_2, \ldots, a_{n-1} which does not divide an2020an2an1 a_{n-2020} \cdots a_{n-2} a_{n-1} . We aim to prove that every sufficiently large number appears in the sequence.

### Proof:

Claim: For sufficiently large n n , the least common multiple (LCM) of a set S S of n n natural numbers satisfies lcm(S)>n4040 \text{lcm}(S) > n^{4040} .

This claim is intuitive and can be shown through detailed analysis, which is omitted here for brevity.

Claim: The ratio ann \frac{a_n}{n} is bounded by a constant.

Proof:
Assume, for contradiction, that ann \frac{a_n}{n} is not bounded. Define a number t t as "good" if att>ass \frac{a_t}{t} > \frac{a_s}{s} for all s<t s < t . Pick a sufficiently large good t t such that att=r2 \frac{a_t}{t} = r \ge 2 .

Let T={1,2,,at}{a1,a2,,at} T = \{1, 2, \ldots, a_t\} \setminus \{a_1, a_2, \ldots, a_t\} . Since Trtt |T| \ge rt - t , by our earlier claim, lcm(T)>((r1)t)4040>(rt)2020>at2020at2019at1 \text{lcm}(T) > ((r-1)t)^{4040} > (rt)^{2020} > a_{t-2020} a_{t-2019} \cdots a_{t-1} . Since lcm(T)at2020at2019at1 \text{lcm}(T) \nmid a_{t-2020} a_{t-2019} \cdots a_{t-1} , there exists an element in T T smaller than at a_t that does not divide at2020at2019at1 a_{t-2020} a_{t-2019} \cdots a_{t-1} . This contradicts the definition of at a_t , as that element would have been chosen instead of at a_t . Therefore, ann \frac{a_n}{n} must be bounded by some constant c c .

Now, assume for contradiction that there exists a sufficiently large number kc k \gg c that does not appear in the sequence. Let k k have a sufficiently large prime power factor, say pαc p^\alpha \gg c . For all t>k t > k , since kat k \neq a_t , pαkat2020at2019at1 p^\alpha \mid k \mid a_{t-2020} a_{t-2019} \cdots a_{t-1} . This implies q=pα2020c q = p^{\lceil \frac{\alpha}{2020} \rceil} \gg c divides one of the terms at2020,at2019,,at1 a_{t-2020}, a_{t-2019}, \ldots, a_{t-1} . If at a_t is divisible by q q , call t t "friendly".

For some nk n \gg k , since at least n n numbers in {1,,k+2020n} \{1, \ldots, k + 2020n\} are friendly, one of the numbers a1,,ak+2020n a_1, \ldots, a_{k + 2020n} is at least qn>kc+2020cn qn > kc + 2020cn . This contradicts the claim that ann \frac{a_n}{n} is bounded by c c .

Therefore, every sufficiently large number must appear in the sequence.

The answer is: \boxed{\text{Every sufficiently large number appears in the sequence}}.

Source: Omni-MATH, licensed Apache-2.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic, difficulty and ordering added by this site.