Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /275 of 310

, 2013

Number theory Difficulty 3.7 AMC 10/12 Find the answer Canada

There are two ways of choosing six different numbers from the list 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,91,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9 so that the product of the six numbers is a perfect square. Suppose that these two perfect squares are m2m^2 and n2n^2, with mm and nn positive integers and mnm \neq n. What is the value of m+nm+n?

Pick one

Solution

We rewrite the integers from the list in terms of their prime factorizations: 1,21,31,22,51,2131,71,23,321,2^1,3^1, 2^2, 5^1, 2^1 3^1, 7^1, 2^3, 3^2 A positive integer larger than one is a perfect square if and only if each of its prime factors occurs an even number of times.

Since the integers in the list above contain in total only one factor of 5 and one factor of 7, then neither 5 nor 7 can be chosen to form a product that is a perfect square.

This leaves us with seven integers 1,21,31,22,2131,23,321,2^1,3^1, 2^2, 2^1 3^1, 2^3, 3^2, from which we need to choose six.

When the seven given integers are multiplied together, their product is 21+2+1+331+1+2=27342^{1+2+1+3}3^{1+1+2}=2^7 3^4.

We can think of choosing six of the seven numbers and multiplying them together as choosing all seven and then dividing out the one we did not choose.

To divide the product 27342^7 3^4 by one of the integers to obtain a perfect square, the divisor must include an odd number of factors of 2 (since the product of all seven includes an odd number of factors of 2) and an even number of factors of 3 (since the product includes an even number of factors of 3). (Note that “an even number of factors of 3" includes the possibility of zero factors of 3.)

There are two such numbers in the list: 212^1 and 232^3.

(Alternatively, we could have divided the product by each of the seven numbers to determine which results in a perfect square.)

Therefore, the two sets of six numbers that satisfy the given conditions should be 1,31,22,2131,23,321,3^1, 2^2, 2^1 3^1, 2^3, 3^2 (whose product is 26342^6 3^4) and 1,21,31,22,2131,321,2^1,3^1, 2^2, 2^1 3^1, 3^2 (whose product is 24342^4 3^4).

Thus, we can set m2=2634m^2 = 2^6 3^4, which gives m=2332=72m=2^3 3^2=72, and n2=2434n^2 = 2^4 3^4, which gives n=2232=36n=2^2 3^2 = 36.

Finally, m+n=72+36=108m+n=72+36=108.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,444 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: CEMC, University of Waterloo, licensed CC-BY-NC-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.