Problem:
Let be a positive integer, and let denote the set of all subsets of . Call a subset of -good if for all , , , where denotes symmetric difference (the symmetric difference of two sets is the set of elements that is in exactly one of the two sets). Find the largest possible integer such that there exists an integer and a -good set of size .
, 2017
Solution
Solution:
Answer: 2048
Let . Let the sets in be . We bound the sum in two ways. On one hand, by the condition we have the obvious bound
On the other hand, for , let . Then it is clear that
by AM-GM. Therefore, we get the bound
To give a construction with , take . For the rest of this construction, we will be interpreting the integers as 11-digit integers in binary. Given this interpretation, define a dot product of two positive integers the following way. If in binary, then
Now we can define the sets . Define
A computation shows that this construction works.
Some notes: here is the motivation behind the construction. We are treating the integers as the vector space , and the sets correspond to linear functionals . In particular, the function is simply defined as , which one can easily check to be linear. This construction corresponds to Hadamard matrices of size .