There are some direct one-way flights among n≥8 airports. Between any two airports a and b, there is at most one direct one-way flight from a to b (it is possible to have direct one-way flights both from a to b and from b to a). Suppose that, for any set A consisting of some airports with 1≤∣A∣≤n−1, there are at least 4⋅min{∣A∣,n−∣A∣} flights in total departing from the airports in A and arriving at the airports not in A. Prove that for any airport x, one can depart from x and take no more than 2n flights to return to x.
Solution
Proof. We represent each airport with a point. If there is a one-way direct flight from airport a to airport b, we draw a directed edge ab, thus obtaining a directed graph G. Let r=⌊2n⌋, then r≥2. We will prove that for any vertex v, there exists a directed cycle passing through v with length at most 2r. This will imply the desired proposition.
We prove by contradiction. Suppose that G does not admit a directed cycle through v of length less than or equal to 2r. For each positive integer k≤r, set Nk={x∈V(G)∣x=v, and the shortest directed path from v to x has length k}, and set Tk=N1∪⋯∪Nk. We first prove the following fact:
(*) For 1≤k≤r−1, if the directed edge xy has source in Tk and target in the complement Tkc, then x∈Nk and y∈Nk+1.
The proof of fact (*) is as follows: Clearly, y=v. Otherwise, we could connect the directed path from v to x of length at most k with the edge xy=xb, obtaining a directed cycle passing through v with length at most 1+k≤r<2r, which is a contradiction. Let x∈Ni (1≤i≤k), then there exists a directed path P from v to x of length i. Connecting P with the edge xy yields a directed path from v to y of length at most i+1. Let d be the length of the shortest directed path from v to y. Then d≤i+1≤k+1. Since y∈(Tk∪v)c, we have d≥k+1, which implies d=k+1 and i=k, i.e., x∈Nk and y∈Nk+1.
Next, we claim that: ∣Tr∣≥2n.
Proof of the claim: We prove by contradiction. Suppose that ∣Tr∣<2n. For each 1≤i≤r−1, consider the set M of all directed edges from Ti to Tic. On the one hand, the condition of the problem implies that ∣M∣≥4⋅min{∣Ti∣,n−∣Ti∣}=4⋅∣Ti∣. On the other hand, (*) implies that for any directed edge xy in M, we have x∈Ni and y∈Ni+1. From this we know that the number of directed edges in M is less than or equal to the ordered pairs (x,y)∈Ni×Ni+1, i.e. ∣M∣≤∣Ni∣⋅∣Ni+1∣. Combining these two discussions, we deduce that, for any 1≤i≤r−1, we have 4⋅∣Ti∣≤∣Ni∣⋅∣Ni+1∣.(1) Put ti=∣Ti∣=∣N1∣+⋯+∣Ni∣. From the given conditions, we see that t1=∣N1∣≥4=22. Using (*), we know that all directed edges xy from T1 to its complement T1c all satisfy y∈N2. In particular, ∣N2∣≥1. So ∣N1∣≤∣T2∣−1≤∣Tr∣−1<2n−1. Similarly to (*), one can prove all directed edges xy from {v}∪N1 to its complement satisfy x∈N1,y∈N2.
So we have ∣N1∣⋅∣N2∣≥4⋅min{1+∣N1∣,n−1−∣N1∣}=4(1+∣N1∣). We deduce from this that t2=∣N1∣+∣N2∣≥∣N1∣+∣N1∣4(1+∣N1∣)>∣N1∣+4≥8, Thus, we have t2≥9=32.
Based on this, we use induction to prove that, for 1≤k≤r, we have tk≥(k+1)2. Suppose that for some 3≤m≤r, we have tm−2≥(m−1)2 and tm−1≥m2. Using (1), we know that, for 1≤i≤r−1, we have 4ti≤(ti−ti−1)(ti+1−ti). Thus, we have tm≥tm−1+tm−1−tm−24tm−1=tm−2+(tm−1−tm−2)+tm−1−tm−24tm−1≥tm−2+24tm−1≥(m−1)2+24m2=(m+1)2, This completes the inductive proof and therefore, ∣Tr∣≥(r+1)2=(⌊2n⌋+1)2>2n, contradicting with earlier assumption ∣Tr∣<2n! This proves the claim.
Similarly, define Ki={x∈V(G)∣x=v, and the shortest directed path from x to v has length i} and put Ui=K1∪⋯∪Ki. Symmetrically, one can prove that ∣Ur∣≥2n.
Finally, note that both Tr and Ur are subsets of V(G)∖{v} and we have ∣Tr∣≥2n and ∣Ur∣≥2n. So the intersection of Tr and Ur is nonempty. Take x∈Tr∩Ur, then there is a directed path from v to x of length ≤r and there is a directed path from x to v of length ≤r. Combining these two gives a directed cycle through v of length less than or equal to 2r. Contradiction! □
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.