Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /13 of 16

Geometry Difficulty 7.5 National olympiad, round 2 Prove it Japan

In the interior of an acute triangle ABCABC that is not isosceles, there are three distinct points A1,B1,C1A_1, B_1, C_1 such that AB1:CB1=AB:CBAB_1 : CB_1 = AB : CB and AC1:BC1=AC:BCAC_1 : BC_1 = AC : BC. Let A2A_2 be the point symmetric to A1A_1 with respect to the line BCBC, let B2B_2 be the point symmetric to B1B_1 with respect to the line ACAC, and let C2C_2 be the point symmetric to C1C_1 with respect to the line ABAB. Then, all of the following conditions are satisfied.
\bullet The four points A,A2,B,C2A, A_2, B, C_2 are concyclic.
\bullet The four points A,A2,B2,CA, A_2, B_2, C are concyclic.
\bullet The four points B,B2,C,C2B, B_2, C, C_2 are concyclic.
\bullet None of the three points A2,B2,C2A_2, B_2, C_2 lie on the circumcircle of the triangle ABCABC.
Prove that the triangle A1B1C1A_1B_1C_1 and the triangle A2B2C2A_2B_2C_2 are similar.

Solution

For three distinct points X1,X2,X3X_1, X_2, X_3, when the line X1X2X_1X_2 is rotated counterclockwise by an angle θ\theta about X1X_1 to coincide with the line X1X3X_1X_3, this θ\theta is denoted by X2X1X3\angle X_2X_1X_3. Note that differences of 180180^\circ are disregarded. First, we show the following lemma concerning the Circle of Apollonius.

Lemma 1. Let STUSTU be a triangle satisfying STSUST \neq SU, and let ω\omega be a circle passing through SS. When an inversion with center SS is performed, mapping TT and UU to TT' and UU' respectively, the circle ω\omega is the Apollonius circle for the segment TUTU passing through SS if and only if ω\omega is mapped by this inversion to the perpendicular bisector of the segment TUT'U'.

Proof of Lemma 1. Let VV and WW be the intersection points of the internal and external angle bisectors of TSU\angle TSU with the line TUTU respectively, and let VV' and WW' be their respective images under the inversion. From ST:SU=VT:VU=WT:WUST : SU = VT : VU = WT : WU, the circumcircle of the triangle SVWSVW is the Apollonius circle for the segment TUTU passing through SS, so it suffices to show that the circumcircle of the triangle SVWSVW is mapped to the perpendicular bisector of the segment TUT'U' by the inversion. Since VV' and WW' are the intersection points of the internal and external angle bisectors of TSU\angle T'SU' with the circumcircle of the triangle STUST'U' respectively, they are the midpoints of the arc TUT'U' not containing SS and the arc TUT'U' containing SS on the circumcircle of the triangle STUST'U' respectively. Therefore, the image of the circumcircle of triangle SVWSVW under the inversion, which is the line VWV'W', is the perpendicular bisector of the segment TUT'U'. Thus, the lemma is proved. ■

Let ΩA\Omega_A be the Apollonius circle for the side BCBC passing through AA, and similarly define ΩB\Omega_B and ΩC\Omega_C. Note that B1B_1 and B2B_2 lie on ΩB\Omega_B, and C1C_1 and C2C_2 lie on ΩC\Omega_C.

Lemma 2. A1,A2A_1, A_2 lie on ΩA\Omega_A.

Proof of Lemma 2. Since ΩA\Omega_A is symmetric with respect to the line BCBC, A1A_1 is on ΩA\Omega_A if and only if A2A_2 is on ΩA\Omega_A. We will show that A2A_2 lies on ΩA\Omega_A.
Let PP and QQ be the two intersection points of ΩB\Omega_B and ΩC\Omega_C. Then,
BP:CP=APBCAC:APBCAB=AB:AC BP : CP = \frac{AP \cdot BC}{AC} : \frac{AP \cdot BC}{AB} = AB : AC
Therefore, PP lies on ΩA\Omega_A, and similarly for QQ.
Let σ\sigma be the inversion with respect to a circle centered at PP with radius 1. Then, for any points Y,ZY, Z different from PP, the triangle PYZPYZ is similar to the triangle Pσ(Z)σ(Y)P\sigma(Z)\sigma(Y), so we obtain
σ(A)σ(B)=ABAPBP=BCBPCP=σ(B)σ(C). \sigma(A)\sigma(B) = \frac{AB}{AP \cdot BP} = \frac{BC}{BP \cdot CP} = \sigma(B)\sigma(C).
Similarly, σ(A)σ(C)=σ(B)σ(C)\sigma(A)\sigma(C) = \sigma(B)\sigma(C) also holds, so the triangle σ(A)σ(B)σ(C)\sigma(A)\sigma(B)\sigma(C) is equilateral. Also, by Lemma 1, σ(ΩA)\sigma(\Omega_A) is the perpendicular bisector of the segment σ(B)σ(C)\sigma(B)\sigma(C), and similarly for σ(ΩB)\sigma(\Omega_B) and σ(ΩC)\sigma(\Omega_C).
Therefore, σ(Q)\sigma(Q) is the center of the equilateral triangle σ(A)σ(B)σ(C)\sigma(A)\sigma(B)\sigma(C), and the line σ(B)σ(B2)\sigma(B)\sigma(B_2) and the line σ(C)σ(C2)\sigma(C)\sigma(C_2) are symmetric with respect to the line σ(A)σ(Q)\sigma(A)\sigma(Q). Also, the four points σ(B),σ(B2),σ(C),σ(C2)\sigma(B), \sigma(B_2), \sigma(C), \sigma(C_2) are concyclic, and since σ(B)\sigma(B) and σ(C)\sigma(C) are symmetric with respect to the line σ(A)σ(Q)\sigma(A)\sigma(Q), σ(B2)\sigma(B_2) and σ(C2)\sigma(C_2) are also symmetric with respect to the line σ(A)σ(Q)\sigma(A)\sigma(Q). Here, from the condition that B2,C2B_2, C_2 do not lie on the circumcircle of the triangle ABCABC, note that the circumcircle of the triangle σ(A)σ(B)σ(C2)\sigma(A)\sigma(B)\sigma(C_2) and the circumcircle of the triangle σ(A)σ(B2)σ(C)\sigma(A)\sigma(B_2)\sigma(C) are distinct. Since σ(A2)\sigma(A_2) is the intersection point of these two circles other than σ(A)\sigma(A), it lies on the line σ(A)σ(Q)\sigma(A)\sigma(Q), and this line is σ(ΩA)\sigma(\Omega_A), so A2A_2 lies on ΩA\Omega_A.

Let RR be the intersection point, other than AA, of the circumcircle of the triangle ABC1ABC_1 and the circumcircle of the triangle AB1CAB_1C. If the two circles are tangent, then let R=AR = A, and the line ARAR is taken to be the common tangent line to the two circles at AA. Also, since B1,C1B_1, C_1 are points in the interior of the triangle ABCABC, note that RR is different from BB and CC. Then,
BRC=BRA+ARC=BC1A+AB1C=AC2B+CB2A=AA2B+CA2A=CA2B=BA1C. \begin{aligned} \angle BRC &= \angle BRA + \angle ARC \\ &= \angle BC_1A + \angle AB_1C \\ &= \angle AC_2B + \angle CB_2A \\ &= \angle AA_2B + \angle CA_2A \\ &= \angle CA_2B \\ &= \angle BA_1C. \end{aligned}
Therefore, the circumcircle of the triangle A1BCA_1BC also passes through RR. Here, since A1A_1 is a point in the interior of the triangle ABCABC, RR is also different from AA.

Proof of Lemma 3. Let ΓA\Gamma_A be the arc BCBC of the circumcircle of the triangle A1BCA_1BC that contains A1A_1. Let ΓB\Gamma_B be the arc CACA of the circumcircle of the triangle AB1CAB_1C that contains B1B_1. Let ΓC\Gamma_C be the arc ABAB of the circumcircle of the triangle ABC1ABC_1 that contains C1C_1. Then, since A1A_1 is in the interior of the triangle ABCABC, ΓA\Gamma_A is inside the circumcircle of the triangle ABCABC, and the part of the circumcircle of the triangle A1BCA_1BC not containing ΓA\Gamma_A is outside the circumcircle of the triangle ABCABC. Since the same holds for ΓB\Gamma_B and ΓC\Gamma_C, either all of ΓA,ΓB,ΓC\Gamma_A, \Gamma_B, \Gamma_C contain RR, or none of them contain RR. Also, if none of them contain RR, then RR must be on the opposite side of the line BCBC from A1A_1, on the opposite side of the line CACA from B1B_1, and on the opposite side of the line ABAB from C1C_1. But since A1,B1,C1A_1, B_1, C_1 are all in the interior of the triangle ABCABC, this is a contradiction. Thus ΓA,ΓB,ΓC\Gamma_A, \Gamma_B, \Gamma_C all pass through RR.
Here, if we assume P=RP = R (where PP is from Lemma 2), then P=A1=B1=C1P = A_1 = B_1 = C_1, which contradicts the assumption that A1,B1,C1A_1, B_1, C_1 are distinct. So note that PRP \neq R. Let τ\tau be the operation of applying σ\sigma defined in Lemma 2 followed by an inversion centered at σ(R)\sigma(R). By Lemma 1, τ(ΩA)\tau(\Omega_A) is the Apollonius circle for the segment τ(B)τ(C)\tau(B)\tau(C) passing through τ(A)\tau(A).
Furthermore, since the four points A1,B,C,RA_1, B, C, R are concyclic, τ(A1)\tau(A_1) lies on the line τ(B)τ(C)\tau(B)\tau(C). Therefore, τ(A1)\tau(A_1) is the intersection of the internal or external bisector of τ(B)τ(A)τ(C)\angle\tau(B)\tau(A)\tau(C) with the line τ(B)τ(C)\tau(B)\tau(C), and similarly for τ(B1)\tau(B_1) and τ(C1)\tau(C_1). Here, since ΓA,ΓB,ΓC\Gamma_A, \Gamma_B, \Gamma_C all contain RR, τ(ΓA),τ(ΓB),τ(ΓC)\tau(\Gamma_A), \tau(\Gamma_B), \tau(\Gamma_C) all contain the point at infinity τ(R)\tau(R). Therefore, τ(A1),τ(B1),τ(C1)\tau(A_1), \tau(B_1), \tau(C_1) are all intersection points of external angle bisectors with the opposite sides. Also,
τ(B)τ(A1)τ(A1)τ(C)τ(C)τ(B1)τ(B1)τ(A)τ(A)τ(C1)τ(C1)τ(B)=τ(A)τ(B)τ(C)τ(A)τ(B)τ(C)τ(A)τ(B)τ(C)τ(A)τ(B)τ(C)=1. \frac{\tau(B)\tau(A_1)}{\tau(A_1)\tau(C)} \cdot \frac{\tau(C)\tau(B_1)}{\tau(B_1)\tau(A)} \cdot \frac{\tau(A)\tau(C_1)}{\tau(C_1)\tau(B)} = \frac{\tau(A)\tau(B)}{\tau(C)\tau(A)} \cdot \frac{\tau(B)\tau(C)}{\tau(A)\tau(B)} \cdot \frac{\tau(C)\tau(A)}{\tau(B)\tau(C)} = 1.
Therefore, by the converse of Menelaus's Theorem, the three points τ(A1),τ(B1),τ(C1)\tau(A_1), \tau(B_1), \tau(C_1) are collinear. Thus the lemma is proved. ■

Let DD be the intersection of the internal angle bisector of BAC\angle BAC with the line BCBC. This point DD lies on ΩA\Omega_A. Also, let OAO_A be the center of ΩA\Omega_A. Then OAO_A lies on the line BCBC. Therefore,
OAAB=OAAD+DAB=ADOA+CAD=ACD \angle O_A A B = \angle O_A A D + \angle D A B = \angle A D O_A + \angle C A D = \angle A C D
from which it follows that the line AOAAO_A is tangent to the circumcircle of triangle ABCABC at AA, so OAA2=OABOACO_A A^2 = O_A B \cdot O_A C holds. From this and OAA=OAA2O_A A = O_A A_2, OAA22=OABOACO_A A_2^2 = O_A B \cdot O_A C holds. Therefore, the line A2OAA_2 O_A is tangent to the circumcircle of the triangle A2BCA_2 BC at A2A_2. Also, under the inversion with respect to ΩA\Omega_A, BB and CC are interchanged, and since P,QP, Q defined in Lemma 2 are invariant, ΩB\Omega_B and ΩC\Omega_C are interchanged by this inversion.
Therefore, if B2B'_2 is the image of C2C_2 under this inversion, then B2B'_2 lies on ΩB\Omega_B. Here, the four points B,B2,C,C2B, B'_2, C, C_2 are concyclic, and this circle is invariant under the inversion with respect to ΩA\Omega_A, so B2=B2B'_2 = B_2. Therefore, OAO_A lies on the line B2C2B_2 C_2, and since OAA22=OAB2OAC2O_A A_2^2 = O_A B_2 \cdot O_A C_2, the circumcircle of the triangle A2B2C2A_2B_2C_2 is tangent to the line A2OAA_2O_A. Therefore,
A1B1C1=A1RC1=A1RB+BRC1=A1CB+BAC1=BCA2+C2AB=BCA2+C2A2B=BA2OA+C2A2OA+OAA2B=C2A2OA=C2B2A2 \begin{aligned} \angle A_1B_1C_1 &= \angle A_1RC_1 \\ &= \angle A_1RB + \angle BRC_1 \\ &= \angle A_1CB + \angle BAC_1 \\ &= \angle BCA_2 + \angle C_2AB \\ &= \angle BCA_2 + \angle C_2A_2B \\ &= \angle BA_2O_A + \angle C_2A_2O_A + \angle O_A A_2B \\ &= \angle C_2A_2O_A \\ &= \angle C_2B_2A_2 \end{aligned}

and, similarly A1C1B1=B2C2A2\angle A_1C_1B_1 = \angle B_2C_2A_2, so the result is shown.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.