Let α<23−5 be a positive real number. Prove that there exist positive integers n and p>α⋅2n for which one can select 2p pairwise distinct subsets S1,…,Sp,T1,…,Tp of the set {1,2,…,n} such that Si∩Tj=∅ for all 1≤i,j≤p.
Solution
Let k and m be positive integers (to be determined later) and set n=km. Decompose the set {1,2,…,n} into k disjoint subsets, each of size m; denote these subsets by A1,…,Ak. Define the following families of sets: ST1={S⊂{1,2,…,n}:∀iS∩Ai=∅},={T⊂{1,2,…,n}:∃iAi⊂T},T=T1∖S. For each set T∈T⊂T1, there exists an index 1≤i≤k such that Ai⊂T. Then for all S∈S, S∩T⊃S∩Ai=∅. Hence, each S∈S and each T∈T have at least one common element.
Below we show that the numbers m and k can be chosen such that ∣S∣,∣T∣>α⋅2n. Then, choosing p=min{∣S∣,∣T∣}, one can select the desired 2p sets S1,…,Sp and T1,…,Tp from families S and T, respectively. Since families S and T are disjoint, sets Si and Tj will be pairwise distinct.
To count the sets S∈S, observe that each Ai has 2m−1 nonempty subsets so we have 2m−1 choices for S∩Ai. These intersections uniquely determine set S, so ∣S∣=(2m−1)k(1) Similarly, if a set H⊂{1,2,…,n} does not contain a certain set Ai then we have 2m−1 choices for H∩Ai: all subsets of Ai, except Ai itself. Therefore, the complement of T1 contains (2m−1)k sets and ∣T1∣=2km−(2m−1)k(2) Next consider the family S∖T1. If a set S intersects all Ai but does not contain any of them, then there exists 2m−2 possible values for each S∩Ai: all subsets of Ai except ∅ and Ai. Therefore the number of such sets S is (2m−2)k, so ∣S∖T1∣=(2m−2)k(3) From (1), (2), and (3) we obtain ∣T∣=∣T1∣−∣S∩T1∣=∣T1∣−(∣S∣−∣S∖T1∣)=2km−2(2m−1)k+(2m−2)k Let δ=23−5 and k=k(m)=[2mlogδ1]. Then m→∞lim2km∣S∣=m→∞lim(1−2m1)k=exp(−m→∞lim2mk)=δ and similarly m→∞lim2km∣T∣=1−2m→∞lim(1−2m1)k+m→∞lim(1−2m2)k=1−2δ+δ2=δ Hence, if m is sufficiently large then 2mk∣S∣ and 2mk∣T∣ are greater than α (since α<δ). So ∣S∣,∣T∣>α⋅2mk=α⋅2n.
Looking for a route rather than an archive? The track puts 2,000
problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.