For an integer n≥4, if a sequence of real numbers x1,x2,…,xn satisfies the following three equalities: x1+x2+⋯+xnx12+x22+⋯+xn2x13+x23+⋯+xn3=n,=2n,=3n, then we call (x1,x2,…,xn) a *regular* n-tuple. We call the difference between the maximal and the minimal elements in x1,x2,…,xn the *width* of the regular n-tuple.
(1) Find the maximal real number C such that, for any integer n≥4, the width of every regular n-tuple is at least C.
(2) For the maximum C in (1), prove that there exists a real number λ>0 such that, for any integer n≥4, the width of every regular n-tuple exceeds C+n1.5λ.
Solution
(1)
Solution 1 We attempt to use the idea of a local inequality to prove that a number a lies between the minimum and maximum of a regular n-tuple. To this end, we consider an indeterminate b and consider the polynomial f(x)=(x−a)(x−b)2=x3−(a+2b)x2+(2ab+b2)x−ab2, and define S=k=1∑nf(xk)=3n−(a+2b)⋅2n+(2ab+b2)⋅n−ab2⋅n. We require S=0 to ensure that f(x1),f(x2),…,f(xn) have both positive and negative values (or are all 0), implying that the numbers x1,x2,…,xn include values ≥a and values ≤a (or x1,…,xn are all equal to b). This ensures a lies between the minimum and maximum values. Setting S=0, we obtain the quadratic equation (1−a)b2+(2a−4)b+(3−2a)=0. This equation has real roots if and only if Δ=(2a−4)2−4(1−a)(3−2a)=4(−a2+a+1)≥0, which is equivalent to 21−5≤a≤21+5. Thus, the maximum value ≥21+5 and the minimum value ≤21−5. The width is therefore ≥21+5−21−5=5. On the other hand, we can construct a regular n-tuple whose width approaches 5 arbitrarily closely. Take positive integers u1,v1,u2,v2 such that u1v1>25−1>u2v2. Define the first group (multiset) to include u12 instances of 1+u1v1 and v12 instances of 1−v1u1. The mean of these u12+v12 numbers is 1, the mean square is 2, and the mean cube is 4+(u1v1−v1u1)>3.
Define the second group (multiset) to include u22 instances of 1+u2v2 and v22 instances of 1−v2u2. The mean of these u22+v22 numbers is 1, the mean square is 2, and the mean cube is 4+(u2v2−v2u2)<3. By combining sufficient numbers of the first and second groups, the overall mean cube can be made exactly 3, and the width (1+u1v1)−(1−v2u2)=u1v1+v2u2 can approach 5 arbitrarily closely. Hence, the largest possible real number C=5. □
Solution 2 (The construction of regular n-tuples is the same as in Solution 1.) Let A and B denote the minimum and maximum values among x1,x2,…,xn, respectively. For each xk−A≥0, applying the Cauchy–Schwarz inequality, we have k=1∑n(xk−A)⋅k=1∑n(xk−A)3≥(k=1∑n(xk−A)2)2. Substituting k=1∑n(xk−A)k=1∑n(xk−A)2k=1∑n(xk−A)3=(k=1∑nxk)−nA=n−nA,=2n−2nA+nA2,=3n−6nA+3nA2−nA3, we find that (1−A)(3−6A+3A2−A3)−(2−2A+A2)2=A2−A−1≥0. Solving, we obtain A≤21−5. Similarly, using the same inequality for B−xk≥0, we find that B≥21+5. Thus, the width B−A≥5. If we have an equality, then A=21−5, B=21+5, and all x1,…,xn are either A or B. This requires 105−5n numbers equal to A and 105+5n numbers equal to B, which cannot hold if n is not divisible by 10. Therefore, the width B−A>5. □
(2)
Consider a linear transformation that maps the approximate minimum value 21−5 to 0 and the approximate maximum value 21+5 to 1. Let zi=5xi−21−5, i.e., xi=21−5+5zi. Denote p=105+5=255+1. Then, we have z1+z2+⋯+zn=pn,z12+z22+⋯+zn2=pn,z13+z23+⋯+zn3=pn. Let ∥x∥ denote the distance of a real number x to the nearest integer. It is well-known that ∥x+y∥≤∥x∥+∥y∥ for any real numbers x,y. Let m be the integer closest to pn, then ∥pn∥=m−255+1n=25(2m−n)5−n=254⋅(2m−n)5+n5m2−5mn+n2≥254⋅2n+11.
From (1), we know that the maximum of z1,z2,…,zn is ≥1, and the minimum is ≤0. Let the difference between the maximum and minimum values be 1+δ, so z1,z2,…,zn∈[−δ,1+δ]. We aim to prove that δ>5n1.5λ. First, assume δ≤21. Consider the polynomial h(z)=1−3z2+2z3=(1+2z)(1−z)2. When z∈[−δ,21], ∥z∥=∣z∣, we have ∥h(z)∥≤∣1−h(z)∣=(3−2z)z2≤(3+2δ)z2≤4z2=4∥z∥2. When z∈[21,1+δ], ∥z∥=∣z−1∣, we have ∥h(z)∥≤∣h(z)∣=(1+2z)(1−z)2≤(3+2δ)(1−z)2≤4(1−z)2=4∥z∥2. Thus, in all cases, ∥h(zk)∥≤4∥zk∥2. Since ∑k=1nh(zk)=n−3⋅pn+2⋅pn=n−pn, it follows that k=1∑n∥h(zk)∥≥∥pn∥, and (∥z1∥+∥z2∥+⋯+∥zn∥)2≥∥z1∥2+∥z2∥2+⋯+∥zn∥2≥41∥pn∥. On the other hand, consider the polynomial g(z)=2z(1−z). When z∈[0,1], we have g(z)=2z(1−z)≥max{z,1−z}=∥z∥. When z∈[−δ,0]∪[1,1+δ], we have g(z)≥−2(δ+δ2)≥∥z∥−4δ. Thus, g(zk)≤∥zk∥−4δ. Since ∑k=1ng(zk)=2∑k=1nzk−2∑k=1nzk2=0, we have 4nδ≥k=1∑n∥zk∥≥41∥pn∥≥251⋅2n+11>11n1. Thus, δ>4111⋅n1.51>65n1.51.
Hence, the width of the regular n-tuple (x1,x2,…,xn) satisfies >5+6n1.51, and λ=61 meets the requirement. □
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.