For any point X inside an acute-angled triangle ABC we define f(X)=A1XAX⋅B1XBX⋅C1XCX where A1,B1, and C1 are the intersection points of the lines AX,BX, and CX with the sides BC,AC, and AB, respectively. Let H,I, and G be the orthocenter, the incenter, and the centroid of the triangle ABC, respectively. Prove that f(H)≥f(I)≥f(G).
Solution
Let a=BC, b=AC, c=AB, and ∠A=α, ∠B=β, ∠C=γ. Let AH1, BH2, CH3 be altitudes, AL1, BL2, CL3 be angle bisectors, and AM1, BM2, CM3 be medians of △ABC. Then L1IAI=ab+c,L2IBI=ba+c,L3ICI=ca+b. Since AG:GM1=BG:GM2=CG:GM3=2:1, we have f(G)=M1GAG⋅M2GBG⋅M3GCG=2⋅2⋅2=8. Hence, f(I)=L1IAI⋅L2IBI⋅L3ICI=ab+c⋅ba+c⋅ca+b≥a2bc⋅b2ac⋅c2ab=8=f(G), i.e. f(I)≥f(G) with the equality if and only if a=b=c.
Further,
HH1=BH1⋅tg∠HBH1==(ABcosβ)⋅tg(90∘−γ)=sinγc⋅cosβ⋅cosγ and AH=cos∠HAH2AH2=cos(90∘−γ)AB⋅cosα=sinγc⋅cosα. So we get H1HAH=cosβcosγcosα. Similarly, H2HBH=cosαcosγcosβ and H3HCH=cosαcosβcosγ. Therefore, f(H)=H1HAH⋅H2HBH⋅H3HCH=cosαcosβcosγ1. Let m=tg2α, n=tg2β and k=tg2γ. By condition, α,β,γ∈(0∘,90∘), so m,n,k∈(0,1). Therefore, f(H)=cosαcosβcosγ1=1−m21+m2⋅1−n21+n2⋅1−k21+k2 We have ab+c=ab+ac=sinαsinβ+sinαsinγ=sin(180∘−(β+γ))2sin2β+γcos2β−γ==sin(β+γ)2sin2β+γcos2β−γ=cos2β+γcos2β−γ=cos2βcos2γ−sin2βsin2γcos2βcos2γ+sin2βsin2γ==1−tg2βtg2γ1+tg2βtg2γ=1−nk1+nk. Similarly, ba+c=1−mk1+mk and ca+b=1−mn1+mn. So, f(I)=ca+b⋅ab+c⋅bc+a=1−mn1+mn⋅1−nk1+nk⋅1−km1+km Thus, f(H)≥f(I)⟺1−m21+m2⋅1−n21+n2⋅1−k21+k2≥1−mn1+mn⋅1−nk1+nk⋅1−km1+km Lemma. If x,y∈(0,1), then 1−x21+x2⋅1−y21+y2≥(1−xy1+xy)2 with the equality if and only if x=y. Proof. We have 1−x21+x2⋅1−y21+y2≥(1−xy1+xy)2⟺(1+x2)(1+y2)(1−xy)2≥(1−x2)(1−y2)(1+xy)2⟺(1+x2y2+x2+y2)(1+x2y2−2xy) ≥(1+x2y2−x2−y2)(1+x2y2+2xy). Let z=1+x2y2, t=x2+y2, w=2xy, then (z+t)(z−w)≥(z−t)(z+w)⟺zt≥zw⟺t≥w⟺⟺x2+y2≥2xy⟺(x−y)2≥0, which finishes the proof of the lemma. By the lemma, (1−m21+m2⋅1−n21+n2)(1−n21+n2⋅1−k21+k2)(1−k21+k2⋅1−m21+m2)≥≥(1−mn1+mn)2(1−nk1+nk)2(1−km1+km)2, i.e. (1−m21+m2⋅1−n21+n2⋅1−k21+k2)2≥(1−mn1+mn⋅1−nk1+nk⋅1−km1+km)2, with equality if and only if m=n=k, which gives the required statement of the problem.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.
Source: MathNet,
licensed CC-BY-4.0.
Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.