There were students participating in a competition and each student solved exactly three problems. For any two students there is exactly one problem which they both solved, while each problem was solved by exactly students. For which positive integers and is that possible?
(Moscow olympiad 1947)
Solution
For each problem was solved by only one student. That means that there are no other students, due to the condition that for any two students there is exactly one problem which they both solved.
Now let .
Let be one of the students. He solved exactly three problems, but each of these three problems was solved by more students. However, these students are all distinct, because there are no two students who solved same two problems. On the other hand, besides student and these students there are no others, because every student solved one of the problems solved by . Therefore the number of the students is .
Let us now determine the number of the problems. Every student solved three problems, but every problem was solved by students. Therefore the number of the problems is and it has to be a positive integer.
Using the formula above for we get
from which it follows that divides , which implies ().
For we have students and problems .
For we have students and problems. For example, we can have:
For we would have students and problems. Then number of the pairs of the problems would be . However, number of the pairs of the problems solved by the same student is , because there are no two students who solved same two problems. Since , this situation cannot happen.
Hence, the only possibilities are .