Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / Slovenian Mathematical Olympiad /63 of 68

Slovenian Mathematical Olympiad, 2008

Geometry Difficulty 6.7 National Olympiad Prove it Slovenia

Let AA, BB, CC, DD and EE be consecutive points on a circle with the centre at OO, such that ∣AC∣=∣BD∣=∣CE∣=∣DO∣|AC| = |BD| = |CE| = |DO|. Let H1H_1, H2H_2 and H3H_3 be the orthocentres of the triangles ACDACD, BCDBCD and BCEBCE. Prove that H1H2H3H_1H_2H_3 is a right triangle.

Solutions — 3

Solution 1

This problem has several interesting solutions. A nicely drawn figure suggests that quadrilaterals ABH1H2ABH_1H_2 and H2H3DEH_2H_3DE are parallelograms. We will prove this fact.

Figure 1

Triangles ACDACD, BCDBCD and BDEBDE are obtuse, so let us first make a short detour examining some properties of obtuse triangles. Let KLMKLM be a triangle with the obtuse angle ∠KLM\angle KLM and let HH be the orthocentre. The point HH lies outside the triangle KLMKLM and on a different side of the line KLKL than MM. Let L′L' and K′K' be the feet of the altitudes from LL and KK. Since ∠ML′H=∠MK′H\angle ML'H = \angle MK'H, points MM, L′L', K′K', HH are concyclic and ∠KML=∠LHK\angle KML = \angle LHK.
The following fact is also worth mentioning: since K′KMK'KM is a right triangle the angle K′KMK'KM is acute. Points K′K', KK, L′L', LL are concyclic, so ∠HLM=π−∠K′KL\angle HLM = \pi - \angle K'KL, and the angle ∠HLM\angle HLM is obtuse.

Figure 2

Let us now return to the original problem. Here to help us are the facts stated above and a new and less cluttered figure.
Since ∣AC∣=∣BD∣|AC| = |BD|, the inscribed angles over these two chords are equal, so ∠ADC=∠BAD\angle ADC = \angle BAD, which implies ∠CBA=π−∠ADC=π−∠BAD=∠DCB\angle CBA = \pi - \angle ADC = \pi - \angle BAD = \angle DCB, so ADAD and BCBC are parallel and ABCDABCD is an isosceles trapezoid.
Figure 3
Points AA, BB, CC and DD are concyclic, so ∠CAD=∠CBD\angle CAD = \angle CBD. From the above consideration we see that ∠DH1C=∠CAD\angle DH_1C = \angle CAD and ∠DH2C=∠CBD\angle DH_2C = \angle CBD,
so ∠DH1C=∠DH2C\angle DH_1C = \angle DH_2C and points CC, H1H_1, H2H_2, DD are concyclic. But H1CH_1C is perpendicular to ADAD, H2DH_2D is perpendicular to BCBC and lines BCBC and ADAD are parallel, so H1CH_1C and H2DH_2D are parallel as well. The cyclic quadrilateral CH1H2DCH_1H_2D has a pair of parallel sides H1CH_1C and H2DH_2D and is therefore an isosceles trapezoid.
We have seen that CH1H2DCH_1H_2D and ABCDABCD are isosceles trapezoids, so we have ∣H1H2∣=∣CD∣=∣AB∣|H_1H_2| = |CD| = |AB|. The altitude AH1AH_1 is perpendicular to the side CDCD and so is the altitude BH2BH_2, hence AH1AH_1 and BH2BH_2 are parallel. The quadrilateral ABH2H1ABH_2H_1 has a pair of parallel sides (BH2BH_2 and AH1AH_1) and a pair of sides of equal length (ABAB and H1H2H_1H_2). Thus, it is either an isosceles trapezoid or a parallelogram. Let us demonstrate that it is, in fact, the latter.
Lines AH1AH_1 and BH2BH_2 are parallel, so the point H1H_1 lies on the side of the line BH2BH_2 not containing CC. As we have shown above the angle ∠DCH1\angle DCH_1 is obtuse, so the angle ∠CH1H2\angle CH_1H_2, which is equal to ∠DCH1\angle DCH_1, is also obtuse. But ∠AH1H2=∠AH1C+∠CH1H2>π2\angle AH_1H_2 = \angle AH_1C + \angle CH_1H_2 > \frac{\pi}{2}, so the angle ∠AH1H2\angle AH_1H_2 is obtuse. On the other hand, the angle ∠CAH1\angle CAH_1 is acute, so ∠BAH1=∠CAH1−∠CAB\angle BAH_1 = \angle CAH_1 - \angle CAB is acute as well (points BB and H1H_1 lie on the same side of the line ACAC, because neither of them lies on the same side as DD). We have shown that ∠BAH1\angle BAH_1 is acute and ∠AH1H2\angle AH_1H_2 is obtuse, so the quadrilateral ABH2H1ABH_2H_1 is a parallelogram. Hence, H1H2H_1H_2 is parallel to ABAB.
Similarly, we show that H2H3H_2H_3 is parallel to EDED. If we wish to prove that ∠H1H2H3=π2\angle H_1H_2H_3 = \frac{\pi}{2}, it suffices to see that lines ABAB and EDED intersect at a right angle.
Denote the intersection of ABAB and EDED by TT. Since ∠BET=∠BED=12∠BOD=30∘\angle BET = \angle BED = \frac{1}{2}\angle BOD = 30^\circ and ∠TBE=π−∠EBA=π−∠ECA=π−120∘=60∘\angle TBE = \pi - \angle EBA = \pi - \angle ECA = \pi - 120^\circ = 60^\circ, we have ∠ETB=π−∠TBE−∠BET=90∘\angle ETB = \pi - \angle TBE - \angle BET = 90^\circ. So ∠ATE=90∘\angle ATE = 90^\circ and this concludes our proof.

Figure 3

Solution 2

Since ∠CH3B=∠BEC=∠BDC=∠CH2B\angle CH_3B = \angle BEC = \angle BDC = \angle CH_2B, points CC, H3H_3, H2H_2, BB are concyclic. Similarly, we show that the quadrilateral CH1H2DCH_1H_2D is cyclic.
Figure 4

We wish to see that ∠H3H2H1=π2\angle H_3H_2H_1 = \frac{\pi}{2}. But ∠H3H2H1=∠H3H2C+∠CH2H1\angle H_3H_2H_1 = \angle H_3H_2C + \angle CH_2H_1 so ∠H3H2C=∠H3BC\angle H_3H_2C = \angle H_3BC and ∠CH2H1=CDH1\angle CH_2H_1 = CDH_1. Let FF be the intersection of lines BH3BH_3 and ECEC and let GG be the intersection of ACAC and DH2DH_2. We wish to show that ∠FBC+∠CDG=π2\angle FBC + \angle CDG = \frac{\pi}{2}.
We will not need the orthocentres this time, so let us draw another figure. Denote α=∠FBC\alpha = \angle FBC and β=∠CDG\beta = \angle CDG. We have to show that α+β=π2\alpha + \beta = \frac{\pi}{2}. We have ∠ECB=π2+α\angle ECB = \frac{\pi}{2} + \alpha and ∠DCA=π2+β\angle DCA = \frac{\pi}{2} + \beta. So, α+β=∠ECB+∠DCA−π=2∠ECA+∠DCE+∠ACB−π=π3+∠DCE+∠ACB\alpha + \beta = \angle ECB + \angle DCA - \pi = 2\angle ECA + \angle DCE + \angle ACB - \pi = \frac{\pi}{3} + \angle DCE + \angle ACB. In particular, ∠ACB=∠CAD\angle ACB = \angle CAD, because the quadrilateral ABCDABCD is an isosceles trapezoid, which implies ∠DCE+∠ACB=∠DAE+∠CAD=∠CAE=12∠COE=30∘\angle DCE + \angle ACB = \angle DAE + \angle CAD = \angle CAE = \frac{1}{2}\angle COE = 30^\circ, so α+β=60∘+30∘=90∘\alpha + \beta = 60^\circ + 30^\circ = 90^\circ and H1H2H3H_1H_2H_3 is a right triangle.

Figure 5

Solution 3

Let the system of coordinates be centred at the circumcentre OO. Since H1H_1 is the orthocentre of the triangle ACDACD we have OH1→=OA→+OC→+OD→\overrightarrow{OH_1} = \overrightarrow{OA} + \overrightarrow{OC} + \overrightarrow{OD}. Similarly,
OH2→=OB→+OC→+OD→andOH3→=OB→+OC→+OE→. \overrightarrow{OH_2} = \overrightarrow{OB} + \overrightarrow{OC} + \overrightarrow{OD} \quad \text{and} \quad \overrightarrow{OH_3} = \overrightarrow{OB} + \overrightarrow{OC} + \overrightarrow{OE}.
So, H1H2→=OH2→−OH1→=OB→−OA→\overrightarrow{H_1H_2} = \overrightarrow{OH_2} - \overrightarrow{OH_1} = \overrightarrow{OB} - \overrightarrow{OA} and H2H3→=OH3→−OH2→=OE→−OD→\overrightarrow{H_2H_3} = \overrightarrow{OH_3} - \overrightarrow{OH_2} = \overrightarrow{OE} - \overrightarrow{OD}.
The inner product of these two vectors is
H1H2→⋅H2H3→=(OB→−OA→)(OE→−OD→)=OB→⋅OE→−OB→⋅OD→−OA→⋅OE→+OA→⋅OD→=∣OB→∣⋅∣OE→∣cos⁡(∠BOE)−∣OB→∣⋅∣OD→∣cos⁡(∠BOD) \begin{aligned} \overrightarrow{H_1H_2} \cdot \overrightarrow{H_2H_3} &= (\overrightarrow{OB} - \overrightarrow{OA})(\overrightarrow{OE} - \overrightarrow{OD}) \\ &= \overrightarrow{OB} \cdot \overrightarrow{OE} - \overrightarrow{OB} \cdot \overrightarrow{OD} - \overrightarrow{OA} \cdot \overrightarrow{OE} + \overrightarrow{OA} \cdot \overrightarrow{OD} \\ &= |\overrightarrow{OB}| \cdot |\overrightarrow{OE}| \cos(\angle BOE) - |\overrightarrow{OB}| \cdot |\overrightarrow{OD}| \cos(\angle BOD) \end{aligned}
−∣OA∣⋅∣OE∣cos⁡(∠AOE)+∣OA∣⋅∣OD∣cos⁡(∠AOD)=∣OA∣2(cos⁡(∠BOE)−cos⁡(∠BOD)−cos⁡(∠AOE)+cos⁡(∠AOD)). \begin{aligned} & - |OA| \cdot |OE| \cos(\angle AOE) + |OA| \cdot |OD| \cos(\angle AOD) \\ &= |OA|^2(\cos(\angle BOE) - \cos(\angle BOD) - \cos(\angle AOE) + \cos(\angle AOD)). \end{aligned}
Here, we used the fact that OO is the centre of the circle containing points AA, BB, DD and EE. Triangles AOCAOC and COECOE are equilateral, so ∠AOE=120∘\angle AOE = 120^\circ. The triangle BODBOD is also equilateral, so ∠BOD=60∘\angle BOD = 60^\circ. Thus,
H1H2→⋅H2H3→=∣OA∣2(cos⁡(∠BOE)−cos⁡(60∘)−cos⁡(120∘)+cos⁡(∠AOD))=∣OA∣2(cos⁡(∠BOE)+cos⁡(∠AOD))=2∣OA∣2cos⁡(∠BOE+∠AOD2)cos⁡(∠BOE−∠AOD2). \begin{aligned} \overrightarrow{H_1H_2} \cdot \overrightarrow{H_2H_3} &= |OA|^2(\cos(\angle BOE) - \cos(60^\circ) - \cos(120^\circ) + \cos(\angle AOD)) \\ &= |OA|^2(\cos(\angle BOE) + \cos(\angle AOD)) \\ &= 2|OA|^2 \cos \left( \frac{\angle BOE + \angle AOD}{2} \right) \cos \left( \frac{\angle BOE - \angle AOD}{2} \right). \end{aligned}
Verify that ∠BOE+∠AOD=2∠BOD+∠DOE+∠AOB\angle BOE + \angle AOD = 2\angle BOD + \angle DOE + \angle AOB, which implies
∠BOE+∠AOD2=∠BOD+∠DOE+∠AOB2=60∘+∠DCE+∠ACB=60∘+∠DCB−∠ECA=60∘+(180∘−30∘)−120∘=90∘=π2, \begin{aligned} \frac{\angle BOE + \angle AOD}{2} &= \angle BOD + \frac{\angle DOE + \angle AOB}{2} = 60^\circ + \angle DCE + \angle ACB \\ &= 60^\circ + \angle DCB - \angle ECA = 60^\circ + (180^\circ - 30^\circ) - 120^\circ = 90^\circ = \frac{\pi}{2}, \end{aligned}
so cos⁡(∠BOE+∠AOD2)=0\cos(\frac{\angle BOE+\angle AOD}{2}) = 0 and H1H2→⋅H2H3→=0\overrightarrow{H_1H_2} \cdot \overrightarrow{H_2H_3} = 0. Hence H1H2H3H_1H_2H_3 is a right triangle.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.