Determine all positive integers for which the following quantity is a positive integer:
, 2015
Solution
For integers and and for a positive integer , let us write if is divisible by . We shall show that are the answer we seek for the problem. Since
we see that satisfy the condition of the problem. We shall show in the sequel that there are no other values of satisfying the condition of the problem.
Since , and do not have prime factors other than 2 and 5 if satisfies the condition of the problem. Also from the fact that it follows that the greatest common divisor of and is either 1 or 2. If is even, then both and are odd, therefore must be divisible by 5, which contradicts the fact that the or 2. Hence we can assume in the sequel that is odd. Then, and are both even. Furthermore, since , is not divisible by 4. In the sequel, we consider various cases separately.
(1) When is not divisible by 5:
is a power of 2, but since it is not divisible by 4, it must be the case that , i.e., . But since is not an integer, we see that does not satisfy the requirement of the problem.
(2) When is divisible by 5:
Since and is not divisible by 4, we can represent , , where are positive integers and . If , then we must have . Let us assume in the sequel that holds. From it follows that . Consequently, is a multiple of 8. If is even, we have , while if is odd, ; therefore, must be even. If we put , where is a positive integer, we get . Since , we can write , where is a positive odd number. Then, from , it follows that holds. If we let , then we get , which is a contradiction. Thus, we must have . In this case, we get , which implies that so that . Consequently, we have .
In summarizing above, we conclude that are the numbers that satisfy the condition of the problem.