Problem:
Determine all integers for which there exists a pair of positive integers with the following properties:
i) No third power of a prime divides .
ii) The equation holds.
Problem:
Determine all integers for which there exists a pair of positive integers with the following properties:
i) No third power of a prime divides .
ii) The equation holds.
Solution:
Let be any prime factor of (such a factor exists because ). Then . Because must be an integer, must also be a prime factor of . Thus , so must also be a prime factor of . By i), can occur in at most quadratically, hence at most twice as often as in . Since this holds for every prime factor, we obtain .
If, on the other hand, a prime factor occurred in at most once, then we would have , contradicting .
Hence we must have . Consequently and thus .
Therefore is the only possible solution. The example with shows that is indeed a solution. ㅁ
Solution:
If we solve condition ii) for , we obtain .
Case 1: . Here, since , the numerator must also vanish, which after substitution gives , i.e. - a contradiction to .
Case 2: . From (1) it follows that
Now we denote by the multiplicity with which a prime factor occurs in the number . If there existed a prime factor with , then by (2) we would have , contradicting i). Hence , and thus divides . From (2) it also follows that and hence , so .
For we would need , which holds for no . Hence only can hold, which is confirmed by the example from the first solution. ㅁ