Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /5 of 7

Geometry Difficulty 8.8 Shortlist Prove it China

Let three circles O\odot O, O1\odot O_1, O2\odot O_2, each externally tangent to the other two, lie on the same side of a line \ell. Let them be tangent to \ell at points AA, A1A_1, A2A_2 respectively, where point AA lies on segment A1A2A_1A_2. Denote the points of tangency of O\odot O with O1\odot O_1 and O2\odot O_2 as B1B_1 and B2B_2 respectively, and the point of tangency of O1\odot O_1 with O2\odot O_2 as CC. Let line A1CA_1C intersect line A2B2A_2B_2 at point D1D_1, and line A2CA_2C intersect line A1B1A_1B_1 at point D2D_2. Prove that line D1D2D_1D_2 is parallel to line \ell.

Solution

Proof 1. Consider the antipodal point PP of AA on the circle O\odot O.
We notice that in the right trapezoid A1A2O1O2A_1A_2O_1O_2, we have O1A1=O1B1O_1A_1 = O_1B_1 and OB1=OAOB_1 = OA.
Therefore,
A1BA=πO1B1A1OB1A=π12(πA1O1O)12(πAOO1)=12(A1O1O+AOO1)=π2, \begin{align*} \angle A_1BA &= \pi - \angle O_1B_1A_1 - \angle OB_1A \\ &= \pi - \frac{1}{2}(\pi - \angle A_1O_1O) - \frac{1}{2}(\pi - \angle AOO_1) \\ &= \frac{1}{2}(\angle A_1O_1O + \angle AOO_1) = \frac{\pi}{2}, \end{align*}
which implies that the line A1B1A_1B_1 passes through point PP. Similarly, A2B2A_2B_2 also passes through point PP.
We have,
D1B2B1=PB2B1=PAB1(P,B2,A,B1 concyclic)=B1A1A=B1CA1( is tangent to O1)=B1CD1. \begin{align*} \angle D_1B_2B_1 &= \angle PB_2B_1 = \angle PAB_1 \quad (P, B_2, A, B_1 \text{ concyclic}) \\ &= \angle B_1A_1A = \angle B_1CA_1 \quad (\ell \text{ is tangent to } \odot O_1) \\ &= \angle B_1CD_1. \end{align*}
Hence, points C,D1,B1,B2C, D_1, B_1, B_2 are concyclic. Similarly, D2D_2 also lies on the circumcircle of CB1B2\triangle CB_1B_2. Therefore,
D1D2B1=D1B2B1=B1A1A. \angle D_1D_2B_1 = \angle D_1B_2B_1 = \angle B_1A_1A.
This implies that D1D2D_1D_2 is parallel to \ell. Proof completed. \Box

Proof 2. We establish a coordinate system with \ell as the xx-axis and AA as the origin. Without loss of generality, let O(0,1)O(0, 1). For i=1,2i = 1, 2, let rir_i be the radius of Oi\odot O_i, which corresponds to the yy-coordinate of point OiO_i. From the equation
xOi2+(ri1)2=(ri+1)2, x_{O_i}^2 + (r_i - 1)^2 = (r_i + 1)^2,
we obtain O1(2r1,r1)O_1(-2\sqrt{r_1}, r_1) and O2(2r2,r2)O_2(2\sqrt{r_2}, r_2) (thus A1(2r1,0)A_1(-2\sqrt{r_1}, 0) and A2(2r2,0)A_2(2\sqrt{r_2}, 0)). Furthermore, due to the tangent property of O1\odot O_1 and O2\odot O_2, we have
[2(r1+r2)]2+(r1r2)2=(r1+r2)2, [2(\sqrt{r_1} + \sqrt{r_2})]^2 + (r_1 - r_2)^2 = (r_1 + r_2)^2,
which simplifies to
()r1+r2=r1r2. (*) \qquad \sqrt{r_1} + \sqrt{r_2} = \sqrt{r_1} \sqrt{r_2}.
On the other hand, we have
AB1=1AO1+r1AOr1+1, \overrightarrow{AB_1} = \frac{1 \cdot \overrightarrow{AO_1} + r_1 \cdot \overrightarrow{AO}}{r_1 + 1},
which yields B1(2r1r1+1,2r1r1+1)B_1(\frac{-2\sqrt{r_1}}{r_1+1}, \frac{2r_1}{r_1+1}). Similarly, we have B2(2r2r2+1,2r2r2+1)B_2(\frac{2\sqrt{r_2}}{r_2+1}, \frac{2r_2}{r_2+1}) and C(2(r1r2r2r1)r1+r2,2r1r2r1+r2)C(\frac{2(r_1\sqrt{r_2}-r_2\sqrt{r_1})}{r_1+r_2}, \frac{2r_1r_2}{r_1+r_2}).

y=2r1r1+12r1r1+1+2r1(x+2r1)=1r1x+2, y = \frac{\frac{2r_1}{r_1+1}}{\frac{-2\sqrt{r_1}}{r_1+1} + 2\sqrt{r_1}}(x + 2\sqrt{r_1}) = \frac{1}{\sqrt{r_1}}x + 2,
and the equation of line CA2CA_2 is given by
y=2r1r2r1+r22(r1r2r2r1)r1+r22r2(x2r2), y = \frac{\frac{2r_1r_2}{r_1+r_2}}{\frac{2(r_1\sqrt{r_2}-r_2\sqrt{r_1})}{r_1+r_2} - 2\sqrt{r_2}} (x - 2\sqrt{r_2}),
which can be combined to obtain
y=2r1r22r1r2(r1r2)2r2(r1+r2)[r1(y2)2r2]. y = \frac{2r_1r_2}{2\sqrt{r_1r_2}(\sqrt{r_1} - \sqrt{r_2}) - 2\sqrt{r_2}(r_1 + r_2)}[\sqrt{r_1}(y - 2) - 2\sqrt{r_2}].
Rearranging the terms, we obtain a linear equation in terms of yy, with the constant term
4r1r2(r1+r2), 4r_1r_2(\sqrt{r_1} + \sqrt{r_2}),
which is a symmetric expression in terms of r1r_1 and r2r_2. The coefficient of yy in this case is (using (*) to convert the expression into a homogeneous form)
2{r1r2r1r1r2(r1r2)+r2(r1+r2)}=2{(r1+r2)2r1r1r2(r1r2)+r2(r1+r2)}=2{r1r1+2r1r2+r2r1r1r2+r2r1+r1r2+r2r2}=2{r1r1+2r1r2+2r2r1+r2r2}, \begin{aligned} & 2\{r_1r_2\sqrt{r_1} - \sqrt{r_1r_2}(\sqrt{r_1} - \sqrt{r_2}) + \sqrt{r_2}(r_1 + r_2)\} \\ &= 2\{(\sqrt{r_1} + \sqrt{r_2})^2\sqrt{r_1} - \sqrt{r_1r_2}(\sqrt{r_1} - \sqrt{r_2}) + \sqrt{r_2}(r_1 + r_2)\} \\ &= 2\{r_1\sqrt{r_1} + 2r_1\sqrt{r_2} + r_2\sqrt{r_1} - r_1\sqrt{r_2} + r_2\sqrt{r_1} + r_1\sqrt{r_2} + r_2\sqrt{r_2}\} \\ &= 2\{r_1\sqrt{r_1} + 2r_1\sqrt{r_2} + 2r_2\sqrt{r_1} + r_2\sqrt{r_2}\}, \end{aligned}
which is also a symmetric expression in terms of r1r_1 and r2r_2.
Therefore, we know that the yy-coordinates of points D1D_1 and D2D_2 have the same expression, which proves the proposition. \square

Proof 3. (In fact, it is not necessary for circle OO to be tangent to line \ell.)
It is easy to see that O,B1,O1O, B_1, O_1 are collinear, O,B2,O2O, B_2, O_2 are collinear, O1,C,O2O_1, C, O_2 are collinear, OB1=OB2OB_1 = OB_2, O1A1=O1B1O_1A_1 = O_1B_1, O2A2=O2B2O_2A_2 = O_2B_2, and O1A1,O2A2O_1A_1, O_2A_2 are both perpendicular to \ell.
Now, we have:
CD1B2=CA1A2+A1A2B2=CA1B1+B1A1A2+A1A2B2=12CO1B1+12A1O1B1+12A2O2B2=(90O1B1C)+12O1OO2=(OB1C90)+90OB1B2=CB1B2. \begin{aligned} \angle CD_1B_2 &= \angle CA_1A_2 + \angle A_1A_2B_2 \\ &= \angle CA_1B_1 + \angle B_1A_1A_2 + \angle A_1A_2B_2 \\ &= \frac{1}{2}\angle CO_1B_1 + \frac{1}{2}\angle A_1O_1B_1 + \frac{1}{2}\angle A_2O_2B_2 \\ &= (90^\circ - \angle O_1B_1C) + \frac{1}{2}\angle O_1OO_2 \\ &= (\angle OB_1C - 90^\circ) + 90^\circ - \angle OB_1B_2 \\ &= \angle CB_1B_2. \end{aligned}
Therefore, C,D1,B1,B2C, D_1, B_1, B_2 are concyclic. Similarly, C,D2,B2,B1C, D_2, B_2, B_1 are concyclic. Hence, C,D1,B1,B2,D2C, D_1, B_1, B_2, D_2 are concyclic. Furthermore, CD1D2=CB1D2=180A1B1C=CA1A2\angle CD_1D_2 = \angle CB_1D_2 = 180^\circ - \angle A_1B_1C = \angle CA_1A_2. Thus, we have D1D2//D_1D_2//\ell. \square

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.