Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /12 of 24

, 2016

Number theory Difficulty 6.4 National olympiad Prove it Argentina

Decide if there is an arithmetic progression of 20162016 natural numbers that are not perfect powers but their product is a perfect power.
(A perfect power is a number of the form nkn^k where nn and kk are natural numbers with n2n \ge 2, k2k \ge 2.)

Solution

For each n3n \ge 3 there exists an arithmetic progression of length nn with these properties. The solution uses the remark that if lNl \in \mathbb{N} is divisible by a prime pp but not by p2p^2—in which case we say that ll is exactly divisible by pp—then ll is not a perfect power.

Start a construction by choosing two primes pp and qq such that n<p<qn < p < q. Consider the arithmetic progression PP with first term pp, common difference qpq-p and length nn; its terms are ak=p+k(qp)a_k = p + k(q-p), k=0,1,,n1k = 0, 1, \dots, n-1. Observe that a0=pa_0 = p is the only term divisible by pp. Indeed, if pp divides aka_k with k1k \ge 1 then pp divides kk or qpq-p. Both are impossible: Since pp is a prime, it divides neither kk (as 0<k<n<p0 < k < n < p) nor qpq-p (as qq is a prime greater than pp). Similarly, a1=qa_1 = q is the only term divisible by qq. If qq divides aka_k with k2k \ge 2 then qq divides k1k-1 or pp. Neither one is possible as qq is prime and 0<k1<n<q0 < k-1 < n < q, p<qp < q. In addition, qq does not divide a0=pa_0 = p since p<qp < q.

Next, let A=a0a1an1A = a_0 a_1 \dots a_{n-1} be the product of the terms of PP. By the above, AA is exactly divisible by pp and qq. Multiply each aka_k by AA to obtain a new progression a0A,a1A,,an1Aa_0 A, a_1 A, \dots, a_{n-1} A of length nn. The product of its terms a0a1an1A=An+1a_0 a_1 \dots a_{n-1} A'' = A^{n+1} is a perfect (n+1)(n+1)-st power. Because pp divides aka_k only for k=0k=0 and AA is exactly divisible by pp, it follows that each of the terms a1A,,an1Aa_1 A, \dots, a_{n-1} A is also exactly divisible by pp, hence not a perfect power. Similarly, since a0=pa_0 = p is not divisible by qq and AA is exactly divisible by qq, the first term a0Aa_0 A of the new progression is exactly divisible by qq. So a0Aa_0 A is not a perfect power, which completes the justification that the progression a0A,a1A,,an1Aa_0 A, a_1 A, \dots, a_{n-1} A satisfies the given conditions.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.