Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /274 of 383

, 2011

Geometry Difficulty 8.8 Shortlist Prove it IMO

Let ABCABC be an acute triangle with circumcircle ω\omega. Let tt be a tangent line to ω\omega. Let ta,tbt_{a}, t_{b}, and tct_{c} be the lines obtained by reflecting tt in the lines BC,CABC, CA, and ABAB, respectively. Show that the circumcircle of the triangle determined by the lines ta,tbt_{a}, t_{b}, and tct_{c} is tangent to the circle ω\omega.

Solutions — 2

Solution 1

To avoid a large case distinction, we will use the notion of oriented angles. Namely, for two lines \ell and mm, we denote by (,m)\angle(\ell, m) the angle by which one may rotate \ell anticlockwise to obtain a line parallel to mm. Thus, all oriented angles are considered modulo 180180^{\circ}.

Figure 1

Denote by TT the point of tangency of tt and ω\omega. Let A=tbtcA' = t_{b} \cap t_{c}, B=tatcB' = t_{a} \cap t_{c}, C=tatbC' = t_{a} \cap t_{b}. Introduce the point AA'' on ω\omega such that TA=AATA = AA'' (ATA'' \neq T unless TATA is a diameter). Define the points BB'' and CC'' in a similar way.

Since the points CC and BB are the midpoints of arcsTC\operatorname{arcs} TC'' and TBTB'', respectively, we have
(t,BC)=(t,TC)+(TC,BC)=2(t,TC)+2(TC,BC)=2((t,TC)+(TC,BC))=2(t,BC)=(t,ta) \begin{aligned} \angle\left(t, B''C''\right) &= \angle\left(t, TC''\right) + \angle\left(TC'', B''C''\right) = 2\angle(t, TC) + 2\angle\left(TC'', BC''\right) \\ &= 2(\angle(t, TC) + \angle(TC, BC)) = 2\angle(t, BC) = \angle\left(t, t_{a}\right) \end{aligned}
It follows that tat_{a} and BCB''C'' are parallel. Similarly, tbACt_{b} \parallel A''C'' and tcABt_{c} \parallel A''B''. Thus, either the triangles ABCA'B'C' and ABCA''B''C'' are homothetic, or they are translates of each other. Now we will prove that they are in fact homothetic, and that the center KK of the homothety belongs to ω\omega. It would then follow that their circumcircles are also homothetic with respect to KK and are therefore tangent at this point, as desired.

We need the two following claims.

Claim 1. The point of intersection XX of the lines BCB''C and BCBC'' lies on tat_{a}.

Proof. Actually, the points XX and TT are symmetric about the line BCBC, since the lines CTCT and CBCB'' are symmetric about this line, as are the lines BTBT and BCBC''.

Claim 2. The point of intersection II of the lines BBBB' and CCCC' lies on the circle ω\omega.

Proof. We consider the case that tt is not parallel to the sides of ABCABC; the other cases may be regarded as limit cases. Let D=tBCD = t \cap BC, E=tACE = t \cap AC, and F=tABF = t \cap AB.

Due to symmetry, the line DBDB is one of the angle bisectors of the lines BDB'D and FDFD; analogously, the line FBFB is one of the angle bisectors of the lines BFB'F and DFDF. So BB is either the incenter or one of the excenters of the triangle BDFB'DF. In any case we have (BD,DF)+(DF,FB)+(BB,BD)=90\angle(BD, DF) + \angle(DF, FB) + \angle\left(B'B, B'D\right) = 90^{\circ}, so
(BB,BC)=(BB,BD)=90(BC,DF)(DF,BA)=90(BC,AB). \angle\left(B'B, B'C'\right) = \angle\left(B'B, B'D\right) = 90^{\circ} - \angle(BC, DF) - \angle(DF, BA) = 90^{\circ} - \angle(BC, AB).
Analogously, we get (CC,BC)=90(BC,AC)\angle\left(C'C, B'C'\right) = 90^{\circ} - \angle(BC, AC). Hence,
(BI,CI)=(BB,BC)+(BC,CC)=(BC,AC)(BC,AB)=(AB,AC), \angle(BI, CI) = \angle\left(B'B, B'C'\right) + \angle\left(B'C', C'C\right) = \angle(BC, AC) - \angle(BC, AB) = \angle(AB, AC),
which means exactly that the points A,B,I,CA, B, I, C are concyclic.

Now we can complete the proof. Let KK be the second intersection point of BBB'B'' and ω\omega. Applying Pascal's theorem to hexagon KBCIBCKB''CIBC'' we get that the points B=KBIBB' = KB'' \cap IB and X=BCBCX = B''C \cap BC'' are collinear with the intersection point SS of CICI and CKC''K. So S=CIBX=CS = CI \cap B'X = C', and the points C,C,KC', C'', K are collinear. Thus KK is the intersection point of BBB'B'' and CCC'C'' which implies that KK is the center of the homothety mapping ABCA'B'C' to ABCA''B''C'', and it belongs to ω\omega.

Solution 2

Define the points T,A,BT, A', B', and CC' in the same way as in the previous solution. Let X,YX, Y, and ZZ be the symmetric images of TT about the lines BC,CABC, CA, and ABAB, respectively. Note that the projections of TT on these lines form a Simson line of TT with respect to ABCABC, therefore the points X,Y,ZX, Y, Z are also collinear. Moreover, we have XBCX \in B'C', YCAY \in C'A', ZABZ \in A'B'.

Denote α=(t,TC)=(BT,BC)\alpha = \angle(t, TC) = \angle(BT, BC). Using the symmetry in the lines ACAC and BCBC, we get
(BC,BX)=(BT,BC)=αand(XC,XC)=(t,TC)=(YC,YC)=α. \angle(BC, BX) = \angle(BT, BC) = \alpha \quad \text{and} \quad \angle\left(XC, XC'\right) = \angle(t, TC) = \angle\left(YC, YC'\right) = \alpha.
Since (XC,XC)=(YC,YC)\angle\left(XC, XC'\right) = \angle\left(YC, YC'\right), the points X,Y,C,CX, Y, C, C' lie on some circle ωc\omega_{c}. Define the circles ωa\omega_{a} and ωb\omega_{b} analogously. Let ω\omega' be the circumcircle of triangle ABCA'B'C'.

Now, applying Miquel's theorem to the four lines AB,AC,BCA'B', A'C', B'C', and XYXY, we obtain that the circles ω,ωa,ωb,ωc\omega', \omega_{a}, \omega_{b}, \omega_{c} intersect at some point KK. We will show that KK lies on ω\omega, and that the tangent lines to ω\omega and ω\omega' at this point coincide; this implies the problem statement.

Due to symmetry, we have XB=TB=ZBXB = TB = ZB, so the point BB is the midpoint of one of the arcsXZ\operatorname{arcs} XZ of circle ωb\omega_{b}. Therefore (KB,KX)=(XZ,XB)\angle(KB, KX) = \angle(XZ, XB). Analogously, (KX,KC)=(XC,XY)\angle(KX, KC) = \angle(XC, XY). Adding these equalities and using the symmetry in the line BCBC we get
(KB,KC)=(XZ,XB)+(XC,XZ)=(XC,XB)=(TB,TC). \angle(KB, KC) = \angle(XZ, XB) + \angle(XC, XZ) = \angle(XC, XB) = \angle(TB, TC).
Therefore, KK lies on ω\omega.

Next, let kk be the tangent line to ω\omega at KK. We have
(k,KC)=(k,KC)+(KC,KC)=(KB,BC)+(XC,XC)=((KB,BX)(BC,BX))+α=(KB,BX)α+α=(KB,BC) \begin{aligned} \angle\left(k, KC'\right) &= \angle(k, KC) + \angle\left(KC, KC'\right) = \angle(KB, BC) + \angle\left(XC, XC'\right) \\ &= (\angle(KB, BX) - \angle(BC, BX)) + \alpha = \angle\left(KB', B'X\right) - \alpha + \alpha = \angle\left(KB', B'C'\right) \end{aligned}
which means exactly that kk is tangent to ω\omega'.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.