Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /345 of 462

Algebra Difficulty 6.5 National Olympiad Prove it Ireland

We say that a doubly infinite sequence
,s2,s1,s0,s1,s2, \dots, s_{-2}, s_{-1}, s_0, s_1, s_2, \dots
is subaveraging if sn=(sn1+sn+1)/4s_n = (s_{n-1} + s_{n+1})/4 for all integers nn.

a. Find a subaveraging sequence in which all entries are different from each other. Prove that all entries are indeed distinct.

b. Show that if (sn)(s_n) is a subaveraging sequence such that there exist distinct integers m,nm, n such that sm=sns_m = s_n, then there are infinitely many pairs of distinct integers i,ji, j with si=sjs_i = s_j.

Solution

a. A sequence (sn)(s_n) is subaveraging iff sn+1=4snsn1s_{n+1} = 4s_n - s_{n-1} for all nZn \in \mathbb{Z}. This is equivalent to sn1=4snsn+1s_{n-1} = 4s_n - s_{n+1} so that we can go backwards by the same recursion. The sequence (sn)(s_n) is completely determined by s0s_0 and s1s_1.

For s0=0s_0 = 0 and s1=1s_1 = 1 we prove by induction that 0sn<sn+10 \le s_n < s_{n+1} for all n0n \ge 0. The start of the induction is clear and for the step we have sn+1=4snsn1>3snsn0s_{n+1} = 4s_n - s_{n-1} > 3s_n \ge s_n \ge 0 for all n1n \ge 1.

Moreover, we obtain s1=1s_{-1} = -1 and so sn=sns_{-n} = -s_n for all n1n \ge 1. This implies sn1<sn0s_{n-1} < s_n \le 0 for all n0n \le 0 and we have shown that all entries of (sn)(s_n) are distinct.

b. If (sk)(s_k) is subaveraging, then the shifted sequence (tk)(t_k) given by tk=sk+nt_k = s_{k+n} is subaveraging as well, because it satisfies the same recursion. The same is true for the reflected sequence (rk)(r_k) given by rk=skr_k = s_{-k}, because the descending recursion sn1=4snsn+1s_{n-1} = 4s_n - s_{n+1} translates into rn+1=4rnrn1r_{n+1} = 4r_n - r_{n-1}.

Assume now that (sk)(s_k) is a subaveraging sequence with sn=sms_n = s_m and n<mn < m. Consider the shifted sequence tk=sk+nt_k = s_{k+n} and the reflected and shifted sequence rk=smkr_k = s_{m-k}. They satisfy t0=r0=snt_0 = r_0 = s_n and tmn=rmn=snt_{m-n} = r_{m-n} = s_n. The difference (dk)(d_k) of these subaveraging sequences, given by dk=tkrkd_k = t_k - r_k, is subaveraging again (because the recursion is linear). We now have d0=dmn=0d_0 = d_{m-n} = 0. If d10d_1 \ne 0, we can divide each term of (dk)(d_k) by d1d_1 and obtain another subaveraging sequence qk=dk/d1q_k = d_k/d_1 with q0=0q_0 = 0 and q1=1q_1 = 1. As we have seen in part (a), all entries of this sequence are distinct. This contradicts mn>0m - n > 0 and qmn=0q_{m-n} = 0. Therefore, d1=0d_1 = 0 and so dk=0d_k = 0 for all kZk \in \mathbb{Z}. This implies that tk=rkt_k = r_k, i.e. sk+n=smks_{k+n} = s_{m-k} for all kZk \in \mathbb{Z}.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.