Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / Bay Area Mathematical Olympiad /12 of 79

Bay Area Mathematical Olympiad

Geometry Difficulty 5.9 AIME, harder Prove it United States

Problem:

In △ABC\triangle ABC, DD and EE are two points on segment BC‾\overline{BC} such that BD=CEBD = CE and ∠BAD=∠CAE\angle BAD = \angle CAE. Prove that △ABC\triangle ABC is isosceles.

Figure 1

Solutions — 4

Solution 1

Solution:

Translate △BDA\triangle BDA horizontally until its side BDBD coincides with side ECEC, and label the image of point AA by A′A'. We now have two triangles △ECA\triangle ECA and △ECA′\triangle ECA' which share the same base ECEC, have the same height (equal to the height AHAH of the original △ABC\triangle ABC), and equal angles ∠EAC\angle EAC and ∠EA′C\angle EA'C. The last implies that there is a circle kk passing through points E,C,A′E, C, A' and AA. The equal heights condition implies that BCBC is parallel to AA′AA'; yet the only trapezoids inscribed in a circle are isosceles. Therefore, ECA′AECA'A is isosceles with AE=A′CAE = A'C. Since the diagonals of an isosceles trapezoid are equal, EA′=CAEA' = CA. Translating back to the original △ABC\triangle ABC, this means that BA=CABA = CA and △ABC\triangle ABC is isosceles.

Figure 2

Solution 2

Solution:

Without loss of generality, assume that the points B,D,EB, D, E and CC are arranged in this order on the line BC↔\overleftrightarrow{BC}; otherwise, switch points DD and EE in the remainder of the solution.

Suppose that △ABC\triangle ABC is not isosceles. Without loss of generality, let BA<CABA < CA. Let ALAL denote the angle bisector of ∠BAC\angle BAC, where LL lies on side BCBC. Reflect △ABL\triangle ABL across ALAL and denote by B′B' and D′D' the images of BB and DD, respectively. Since B′A=BA<CAB'A = BA < CA, B′B' is inside side CACA, and this forces the whole segment LB′LB' to be inside △LCA\triangle LCA; in particular, D′D' is an interior point of segment AEAE.

Because of the reflection, △AD′B′\triangle AD'B' has equal area as △ADB\triangle ADB. In its turn, △ADB\triangle ADB has the equal area as △AEC\triangle AEC (they have equal bases and heights). This implies that △AD′B′\triangle AD'B' and △AEC\triangle AEC have equal area, which contradicts the fact that one triangle is properly included in the other.

We conclude that our supposition is false. Therefore, AB=ACAB = AC and our triangle is isosceles as desired.

Figure 3

Solution 3

Solution:

Let ∠BAD=∠CAE=θ\angle BAD = \angle CAE = \theta. In the end triangles, △ABD\triangle ABD and △ACE\triangle ACE, and △ABC\triangle ABC, by the Law of Sines
asin⁡θ=msin⁡B=nsin⁡Candqsin⁡B=psin⁡C \frac{a}{\sin \theta} = \frac{m}{\sin B} = \frac{n}{\sin C} \quad \text{and} \quad \frac{q}{\sin B} = \frac{p}{\sin C}
Then mp=nqmp = nq. Suppose p≠qp \neq q. Then, without loss of generality, p<qp < q, which implies np<nq=mpnp < nq = mp and n<mn < m. But if p<qp < q then ∠C<∠B\angle C < \angle B which implies ∠AED=∠C+θ<∠B+θ=∠ADE\angle AED = \angle C + \theta < \angle B + \theta = \angle ADE and m<nm < n.

This is a contradiction, so p=qp = q and △ABC\triangle ABC is isosceles.

Solution 4

Solution:

Let ∠BAD=∠CAE=θ\angle BAD = \angle CAE = \theta. △ABD\triangle ABD and △ACE\triangle ACE have equal areas since they have equal bases (BD=EC)(BD = EC) and the same altitude from AA. Then
12pmsin⁡θ=12qnsin⁡θ \frac{1}{2} p m \sin \theta = \frac{1}{2} q n \sin \theta
which implies mp=nqmp = nq. Now use the same contradiction as in the above solution.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.