Problem:
Two sequences of positive integers, and , are given, such that
for each . Prove that there are infinitely many values of such that .
Problem:
Two sequences of positive integers, and , are given, such that
for each . Prove that there are infinitely many values of such that .
Solution:
Suppose the statement is false. So there are only finitely many values for which ; suppose there are such values. Let be the largest integer such that for all (this is possible since every ; note that it may be the case that ). We have for some , say , and since the sequence is decreasing, we then get for all . Letting , we obtain
for all , with at most possible exceptions.
Now fix any positive integer . The pairs of positive integers for are all distinct, since the corresponding values of are strictly increasing; and except for at most of them, the remaining ones all satisfy
and
So we have possible values for (namely ), and for each such value, we have choices for (namely ), giving possible pairs obtained in this way. Hence, counting all the pairs for , we have
But since is fixed, clearly this inequality will become false for large enough . At this point we have a contradiction, and the problem is solved.