For any positive integer let be the largest power of that divides (e.g. , ). Prove that for any positive integers and with , the sum is a fractional number.
Solution
First prove that the largest power of among the numbers , , , is unique. Let be the largest of the numbers , , , . If there were and with such that , then they must be of the form and , where and are odd numbers. Since , we have and . Since is even, the number has a divisor , and , which contradicts the choice of . Thus the largest power of appears only once among the numbers , , , .
Converting the fractions to the common denominator, the fraction with the largest denominator gives in the numerator, all others give a positive power of , i.e. an even number. Consequently the numerator is odd and cannot cancel with the denominator.
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.