Let be an infinite sequence of positive integers such that divides for all positive integers and . Prove that this sequence is eventually periodic, i.e. there exist positive integers and such that for all .
, 2021
Solution
We will make repeated use of the following simple observation:
Lemma 1. If a positive integer divides and for some and , it also divides . If divides and , it also divides .
Proof. Both parts are obvious since divides .
Claim. The sequence is bounded.
Proof. Suppose the contrary. Then there exist infinitely many indices such that is greater than each of the previous terms . Let be such a term, . For each the number divides , therefore
In particular,
that is, and . It follows from Lemma 1 that divides for and divides for . Since at least one of the numbers and is at least , so is some with . However, can be arbitrarily large, a contradiction.
Since is bounded, there exist only finitely many for which appears in the sequence finitely many times. In other words, there exists such that if and , then for infinitely many .
Clearly the sequence satisfies the divisibility condition, and it is enough to prove that this sequence is eventually periodic. Thus truncating the sequence if necessary, we can assume that each number appears infinitely many times in the sequence. Let be the maximum number appearing in the sequence.
Lemma 2. If a positive integer divides for some , then the numbers such that divides form an arithmetical progression with an odd difference.
Proof. Let be all the indices such that divides . If is even, it follows from Lemma 1 that also divides , impossible since . Thus and are always of different parity, and therefore is even. Applying Lemma 1 again, we see that divides , hence .
We are ready now to solve the problem.
The number of positive divisors of all terms of the progression is finite. Let be the difference of the progression corresponding to , that is, divides if and only if it divides for any positive integer . Let be the product of all . Then each dividing a term of the progression divides if and only if it divides . This means that the sets of divisors of and coincide, and . Thus is a period of the sequence.