Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /11 of 14

Geometry Difficulty 8.7 Shortlist Prove it Estonia

There are distinct points OO, AA, BB, K1K_1, \ldots, KnK_n, L1L_1, \ldots, LnL_n on a plane such that no three points are collinear. The open line segments K1L1K_1L_1, \ldots, KnLnK_nL_n are coloured red, other points on the plane are left uncoloured. An allowed path from point OO to point XX is a polygonal chain with first and last vertices at points OO and XX, containing no red points. For example, for n=1n = 1, and K1=(1;0)K_1 = (-1; 0), L1=(1;0)L_1 = (1; 0), O=(0;1)O = (0; -1), and X=(0;1)X = (0; 1), OK1XOK_1X and OL1XOL_1X are examples of allowed paths from OO to XX; there are no shorter allowed paths. Find the least positive integer nn such that it is possible that the first vertex that is not OO on any shortest possible allowed path from OO to AA is closer to BB than to AA, and the first vertex that is not OO on any shortest possible allowed path from OO to BB is closer to AA than to $B.

Solution

A path OX1Xk1AOX_1\ldots X_{k-1}A is suitable if it is a shortest allowed path from OO to AA and X1AX1BX_1A \le X_1B. Similarly, a path OY1Yk1BOY_1\ldots Y_{k-1}B is suitable if it is the shortest allowed path from OO to BB and Y1BY1AY_1B \le Y_1A. Let us show that for n=2n = 2 it is possible to choose points AA, BB, OO, K1K_1, L1L_1, K2K_2, L2L_2 such that no shortest path from point OO to point AA, nor one from point OO to point BB is suitable. Take A=(2;2)A = (2; 2), B=(2;2)B = (-2; -2), K1=(2;1)K_1 = (-2;1), L1=(5;1)L_1 = (5;1), K2=(2;1)K_2 = (2;-1), and L2=(5;1)L_2 = (-5;-1) (Fig. 43).
Figure 1

If O=(0;0)O = (0;0), then the only shortest paths from point OO to points AA and BB are respectively OK1AOK_1A and OK2BOK_2B, whereas K1A>K1BK_1A > K_1B and K2B>K2AK_2B > K_2A, and hence they are not suitable. The collinearity of three points can be avoided by shifting OO slightly while leaving the situation unchanged.

We will show that for n=1n = 1 there exists at least one suitable path from point OO to point AA or point BB. If the segment OAOA or segment OBOB does not contain any red points, then it is suitable. Therefore, assume that both segments OAOA and OBOB contain red points. W.l.o.g., K1AK1BK_1A \le K_1B (can change AA and BB). If OK1AOK_1A is a shortest path from point OO to point AA, then it is suitable. Otherwise, OL1AOL_1A is the only shortest path from point OO to point AA. It is suitable if L1AL1BL_1A \le L_1B. Let us further assume that L1A>L1BL_1A > L_1B. If OL1BOL_1B is a shortest path from point OO to point BB, then it is suitable. Otherwise, OK1BOK_1B is the only shortest path from point OO to point BB. Then OL1+L1A+OK1+K1B<OK1+K1A+OL1+L1BOL_1 + L_1A + OK_1 + K_1B < OK_1 + K_1A + OL_1 + L_1B. This simplifies to K1B+L1A<K1A+L1BK_1B + L_1A < K_1A + L_1B. However, adding the inequalities K1BK1AK_1B \ge K_1A and L1A>L1BL_1A > L_1B gives K1B+L1A>K1A+L1BK_1B + L_1A > K_1A + L_1B. The contradiction shows that at least one suitable path from point OO to point AA or BB exists.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.