The equation
is written on the board. One tries to erase some linear factors from both sides so that each side still has at least one factor, and the resulting equation has no real roots. Find the least number of linear factors one needs to erase to achieve this.
Solution
Since there are 2016 common linear factors on both sides, we need to erase at least 2016 factors. We claim that the equation has no real roots if we erase all factors on the left-hand side with , and all factors on the right-hand side with . Therefore, it suffices to show that no real number satisfies
- Case 1. .
In this case, one side of (1) is zero while the other side is not. This shows cannot satisfy (1).
- Case 2. for in this case.
So each term in the product lies strictly between 0 and 1, and the whole product must be less than 1, which is impossible.
- Case 3. for in this case.
So each term in the product lies strictly between 0 and 1, and the whole product must be less than 1, which is impossible.
- Case 4. for in this case.
So each term in the product lies strictly between 0 and 1, and the whole product must be less than 1, which is impossible.
- Case 5. or .
For , we have . For , we have .
- Case 6. or for .
For , we have . For , we have .
- Case 7. or for .
For , we have . For , we have .
If , one may leave on the left-hand side and on the right-hand side. For , we have . For , we have . For , we have .
If , as the proposer mentioned, the situation is a bit more out of control. Since the construction for works, the answer can be either or . For , we can leave the products and . For , the only example that works is and , while there seems to be no such partition for .