Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /507 of 520

Algebra Difficulty 6.4 National olympiad Find the answer

Let's determine all xx that satisfy the following inequality:

sin2x+sin22x>sin23x \sin ^{2} x+\sin ^{2} 2 x>\sin ^{2} 3 x

A number or a short expression. Spacing and $ signs are ignored.

Solution

The equivalent of the given problem is that the difference - denoted by KK - between the left and right sides is positive for which xx values. Express the second and third terms of KK also in terms of sinx\sin x. Since sin3x=sinx(34sin2x)\sin 3 x=\sin x\left(3-4 \sin ^{2} x\right),

sin22x=4sin2xcos2x=4sin2x(1sin2x)sin23x=sin2x(924sin2x+16sin4x), and thus K=sin2x+sin22xsin23x=sin2x(4+20sin2x16sin4x)==4sin2x(4sin4x5sin2x+1)=4sin2x(sin2x1)(4sin2x1)==4sin2xcos2x(4sin2x1) \begin{gathered} \sin ^{2} 2 x=4 \sin ^{2} x \cos ^{2} x=4 \sin ^{2} x\left(1-\sin ^{2} x\right) \\ \sin ^{2} 3 x=\sin ^{2} x\left(9-24 \sin ^{2} x+16 \sin ^{4} x\right), \text { and thus } \\ K=\sin ^{2} x+\sin ^{2} 2 x-\sin ^{2} 3 x=\sin ^{2} x\left(-4+20 \sin ^{2} x-16 \sin ^{4} x\right)= \\ =-4 \sin ^{2} x\left(4 \sin ^{4} x-5 \sin ^{2} x+1\right)=-4 \sin ^{2} x\left(\sin ^{2} x-1\right)\left(4 \sin ^{2} x-1\right)= \\ =4 \sin ^{2} x \cos ^{2} x\left(4 \sin ^{2} x-1\right) \end{gathered}

(We factored the quadratic polynomial in sin2x\sin ^{2} x using the fact that the roots of the equation 4z25z+1=04 z^{2}-5 z+1=0 are z1=1,z2=1/4z_{1}=1, z_{2}=1 / 4.) The first two factors of the last form are never negative, but can be 0, specifically when - in the (0,360)\left(0^{\circ}, 360^{\circ}\right) interval - x=0,180x=0^{\circ}, 180^{\circ}, or 90,27090^{\circ}, 270^{\circ}. After excluding these xx values, KK is positive if and only if the third factor is positive, that is,

4sin2x>1,sin>0.5 4 \sin ^{2} x>1, \quad|\sin |>0.5

This is satisfied in the intervals 30<x<15030^{\circ}<x<150^{\circ} and 210<x<330210^{\circ}<x<330^{\circ}. The excluded values 9090^{\circ} and 270270^{\circ} fall within these subintervals, so the solution is:

30<x<90,90<x<150,210<x<270,270<x<330 30^{\circ}<x<90^{\circ}, \quad 90^{\circ}<x<150^{\circ}, \quad 210^{\circ}<x<270^{\circ}, \quad 270^{\circ}<x<330^{\circ}

The last two intervals can be derived from the first two by adding 180180^{\circ}, so the general solution can be written more simply. In radians:

π6+kπ<x<π2+kπ and π2+kπ<x<5π6+kπ \frac{\pi}{6}+k \pi<x<\frac{\pi}{2}+k \pi \quad \text { and } \quad \frac{\pi}{2}+k \pi<x<\frac{5 \pi}{6}+k \pi

where kk is an integer.

János Kemenes (Budapest, Konyves Kalman g. III. o. t.)

Remarks. 1. KK can also be expressed in terms of the functions of 2x2 x. By converting the difference and sum of sines into a product:

sin2xsin23x=(sinxsin3x)(sinx+sin3x)==4cos2xsin(x)sin2xcos(x)=2sin22xcos2x, and thus K=sin22x+(sin2xsin23x)=sin22x(12cos2x) \begin{gathered} \sin ^{2} x-\sin ^{2} 3 x=(\sin x-\sin 3 x)(\sin x+\sin 3 x)= \\ =4 \cos 2 x \sin (-x) \sin 2 x \cos (-x)=-2 \sin ^{2} 2 x \cos 2 x, \text { and thus } \\ K=\sin ^{2} 2 x+\left(\sin ^{2} x-\sin ^{2} 3 x\right)=\sin ^{2} 2 x(1-2 \cos 2 x) \end{gathered}

This is positive if and only if

sin22x0 and cos2x<0.5, that is π3+2kπ<2x<5π3+2kπ \begin{gathered} \sin ^{2} 2 x \neq 0 \text { and } \cos 2 x<0.5, \text { that is } \\ \frac{\pi}{3}+2 k \pi<2 x<\frac{5 \pi}{3}+2 k \pi \end{gathered}

The excluded value 2x=n+2kπ2 x=n+2 k \pi falls within the obtained bounds, splitting the interval. Dividing by 2, we arrive at the above result.

Zoltán Demendy (Budapest, Hengersor uti g. IV. o. t.)

2. Several solved the problem graphically, using the usual representations of the terms of KK. This method provides good orientation, but becomes uncertain near the critical points, i.e., where the two sides are equal. Without numerical examination, we cannot confidently state the magnitude relationships in the "small" neighborhood of these points.

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: NuminaMath-1.5, licensed Apache-2.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.