16. (ROM 1) Let and be all natural numbers that are less than and relatively prime to . Show that if is an arithmetic progression, then is a prime number or a natural power of two.
Solution
16. Let be the least prime number that does not divide : thus and . Since , the 's are We have the following cases: . Then and the numbers are relatively prime to , hence is a prime. . Then , so every odd number less than is relatively prime to , from which we deduce that has no odd divisors. Therefore for some . . Then and . Since also must belong to the progression, we have . Let be any prime divisor of . Then also . On the other hand, since , it must divide too, therefore , i.e. . This means that has no prime divisors other than 2 and thus for some . But in order for to be prime, must be even (because for odd). Now we recall that is also relatively prime to ; but is divisible by 3 , which is a contradiction because .