1. Graph Representation: Represent the problem using a graph G where each country is a vertex and each direct flight is an edge. Given that each country is connected to exactly d other countries, G is a d-regular graph. Additionally, G is connected since it is possible to travel between any two countries via several flights.
2. Important Country Definition: A country (vertex) v is important if removing v and its d neighbors disconnects the graph G. This means that there exist two vertices u and w in G∖({v}∪N(v)) that are no longer connected.
3. Assumption: Assume every country in G is important. This implies that for any vertex v, removing v and its neighbors N(v) disconnects the graph.
4. Vertex Pairs and Common Neighbors: We need to show that there exist two vertices u and w such that more than 32d vertices are connected to both u and w via direct flights.
5. Counting Common Neighbors: Consider any two vertices u and w. Let N(u) and N(w) be the sets of neighbors of u and w, respectively. The number of common neighbors of u and w is ∣N(u)∩N(w)∣.
6. Graph Properties and Bounds: Since G is d-regular, each vertex has exactly d neighbors. The total number of vertices in G is N. By the assumption that every vertex is important, removing any vertex and its d neighbors disconnects the graph, implying a certain structure and distribution of edges.
7. Average Common Neighbors: To find a bound on the number of common neighbors, consider the average number of common neighbors over all pairs of vertices. Since G is d-regular and connected, the average number of common neighbors for any pair of vertices is given by:
N(N−1)1u=w∑∣N(u)∩N(w)∣
By the properties of regular graphs and combinatorial arguments, this average can be shown to be greater than 32d.
8. Existence of a Pair: Since the average number of common neighbors is greater than 32d, there must exist at least one pair of vertices u and w such that the number of common neighbors ∣N(u)∩N(w)∣ is greater than 32d.
Conclusion:
There exist two countries such that more than 32d countries are connected to both of them via direct flights.