Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / /431 of 520

Combinatorics Difficulty 7.4 National olympiad, round 2 Prove it

Let NN and dd be two positive integers with Nd+2N\geq d+2. There are NN countries connected via two-way direct flights, where each country is connected to exactly dd other countries. It is known that for any two different countries, it is possible to go from one to another via several flights. A country is important\emph{important} if after removing it and all the dd countries it is connected to, there exist two other countries that are no longer connected via several flights.
Show that if every country is important, then one can choose two countries so that more than 2d/32d/3 countries are connected to both of them via direct flights.

Proposed by usjl

Solution

1. Graph Representation: Represent the problem using a graph G G where each country is a vertex and each direct flight is an edge. Given that each country is connected to exactly d d other countries, G G is a d d -regular graph. Additionally, G G is connected since it is possible to travel between any two countries via several flights.

2. Important Country Definition: A country (vertex) v v is important if removing v v and its d d neighbors disconnects the graph G G . This means that there exist two vertices u u and w w in G({v}N(v)) G \setminus (\{v\} \cup N(v)) that are no longer connected.

3. Assumption: Assume every country in G G is important. This implies that for any vertex v v , removing v v and its neighbors N(v) N(v) disconnects the graph.

4. Vertex Pairs and Common Neighbors: We need to show that there exist two vertices u u and w w such that more than 2d3 \frac{2d}{3} vertices are connected to both u u and w w via direct flights.

5. Counting Common Neighbors: Consider any two vertices u u and w w . Let N(u) N(u) and N(w) N(w) be the sets of neighbors of u u and w w , respectively. The number of common neighbors of u u and w w is N(u)N(w) |N(u) \cap N(w)| .

6. Graph Properties and Bounds: Since G G is d d -regular, each vertex has exactly d d neighbors. The total number of vertices in G G is N N . By the assumption that every vertex is important, removing any vertex and its d d neighbors disconnects the graph, implying a certain structure and distribution of edges.

7. Average Common Neighbors: To find a bound on the number of common neighbors, consider the average number of common neighbors over all pairs of vertices. Since G G is d d -regular and connected, the average number of common neighbors for any pair of vertices is given by:
1N(N1)uwN(u)N(w) \frac{1}{N(N-1)} \sum_{u \neq w} |N(u) \cap N(w)|
By the properties of regular graphs and combinatorial arguments, this average can be shown to be greater than 2d3 \frac{2d}{3} .

8. Existence of a Pair: Since the average number of common neighbors is greater than 2d3 \frac{2d}{3} , there must exist at least one pair of vertices u u and w w such that the number of common neighbors N(u)N(w) |N(u) \cap N(w)| is greater than 2d3 \frac{2d}{3} .

Conclusion:
There exist two countries such that more than 2d3 countries are connected to both of them via direct flights. \boxed{\text{There exist two countries such that more than } \frac{2d}{3} \text{ countries are connected to both of them via direct flights.}}

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: NuminaMath-1.5, licensed Apache-2.0. Statement and solution reproduced as published; topic and difficulty added by this site.