Prove that there is a constant and infinitely many positive integers with the following property: there are infinitely many positive integers that cannot be expressed as the sum of fewer than pairwise coprime powers.
Problem 1847
Official solution
is divisible by for every prime power exactly dividing .
This property ensures that all powers are congruent to or modulo each such prime power , and hence that any sum of pairwise coprime powers is congruent to or modulo , since at most one of the powers is divisible by . Thus, if denotes the number of distinct prime factors of , we find by the Chinese Remainder Theorem at most residue classes modulo which are sums of at most pairwise coprime powers. In particular, if then there are infinitely many positive integers not expressible as a sum of at most pairwise coprime powers.
It thus suffices to prove that there are arbitrarily large pairs of integers satisfying such that
for some positive constant .
We construct such pairs as follows. Fix a positive integer and choose (distinct) prime numbers and ; we set . It is well-known that and , hence
is an integer and the pair ( ) satisfies ( ).
Estimating the size of and is now straightforward. We have
which rearranges to
Solution 2, obtaining better bounds. As in the preceding solution, we seek arbitrarily large pairs of integers and satisfying such that .
This time, to construct such pairs, we fix an integer , set to be the lowest common multiple of , and set to be twice the lowest common multiple of . The pair does indeed satisfy the condition, since if is a prime power divisor of then is a factor of .
Now is the product of all primes having a power lying in the interval ( ], and hence . Thus for sufficiently large we have
using the Prime Number Theorem .
On the other hand, is a product of at most prime powers less than or equal to , and so we have the upper bound
again by the Prime Number Theorem. Combined with the above inequality, we find that for any , the inequality
holds for sufficiently large . Rearranging this shows that
for all sufficiently large and we are done.