Find all prime numbers which satisfy the following condition: For any prime , if , there does not exist an integer such that .
Problem 1613
Official solution
To find all prime numbers which satisfy the given condition, we need to show that for any prime , if with , there does not exist an integer such that .
We will prove that if is prime, there is a prime such that the least residue of modulo is not square-free. In fact, we will prove a stronger statement: if is odd (not necessarily prime), there is a prime such that the least residue of modulo is either , , or .
1. **Assume is a counterexample**:
Suppose that some odd is a counterexample: there is no prime for which the remainder upon dividing by belongs to .
2. **Consider **:
If there is a prime dividing , then is the least residue of modulo , which contradicts our assumption on . Since is odd, is also not divisible by , so the only prime divisor of must be . In other words, for some natural number .
3. **Consider **:
If has any prime factor greater than , we once again contradict our assumption on . Thus, we may assume that all of its prime factors belong to . But is impossible since is odd, and is impossible since is divisible by . Thus, is divisible only by , , or both.
4. **Consider **:
For the same reason as above, it too can only have prime factors among . Since is divisible by and not by , is divisible by neither nor . It may or may not be divisible by , but we claim that in either case, cannot be divisible by . Here's why: If is divisible by , then certainly isn't. If is not divisible by , then it must be a power of (since no other prime factors are available). But powers of can only leave remainders of upon division by , so , which is one greater than a power of , cannot be divisible by .
5. **Conclude is a power of **:
Recall that the only possible prime factors of were and , and we just ruled out . We may therefore conclude that is a power of : . Comparing this with , we obtain:
6. **Solve the equation **:
Reducing modulo , we see that must be even, so for some . Now,
But these factors cannot both be divisible by (they differ by ), so the only way their product can be a power of is if one of them is and the other is a power of . This forces , as required. Thus, the only solution is:
Therefore, the only prime number that satisfies the given condition is .
The final answer is .