Find all the functions such that for :
where
Solution
Lemma 1. For every natural number , is unbounded.
Proof. For every natural number ,
So, send to the infinity, we are done.
Lemma 2. All the terms of the sequence are distinct.
Proof. If and then this sequence becomes periodic which contradicts the first lemma.
Back to our problem, by the first lemma , set , then
We want to prove that . Assume the contrary, by lemma 2, there is no such that , so we have
Set then 1 tells us that for each in the range of , we have . If we use this for we have . Therefore for every natural number we have
Hence which is a proper subset of contains every big enough natural number. This contradicts the fact that members of are distinct. So we should have . Now 1 implies that , by induction we have .
Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track
puts 2,000 problems in a working order, from AMC 10 level to the IMO shortlist.