Maths Olympiad Prep

Library / China Mathematical Olympiad /29 of 37

China Mathematical Olympiad

Combinatorics Difficulty 7.2 National Olympiad, round 2 Prove it China

Given X={1,2,…,100}X = \{1, 2, \dots, 100\}, consider function f:X→Xf: X \to X satisfying both the following conditions:
(1) f(x)≠xf(x) \neq x for all x∈Xx \in X;
(2) A∩f(A)≠∅A \cap f(A) \neq \emptyset for all A⊆XA \subseteq X with ∣A∣=40|A| = 40.

Find the smallest positive integer kk, such that for any such function ff there exists a set B⊆XB \subseteq X satisfying ∣B∣=k|B| = k and B∪f(B)=XB \cup f(B) = X.
Remark. For a subset TT of XX, we define f(T)={x∣there exists t∈T such that x=f(t)}f(T) = \{x \mid \text{there exists } t \in T \text{ such that } x = f(t)\}.

Solution

First, we define a function f:X→Xf: X \to X with
f(3i−2)=3i−1,f(3i−1)=3i,f(3i)=3i−2,i=1,2,…,30,f(j)=100,91≤j≤99,f(100)=99. \begin{aligned} f(3i - 2) &= 3i - 1, \quad f(3i - 1) = 3i, \quad f(3i) = 3i - 2, \\ i &= 1, 2, \dots, 30, \\ f(j) &= 100, \quad 91 \le j \le 99, \quad f(100) = 99.\end{aligned}
Obviously, ff satisfies condition (1). For any A⊆XA \subseteq X with ∣A∣=40|A| = 40, if
(i) there exists an integer ii with 1≤i≤301 \le i \le 30 such that ∣A∩{3i−2,3i−1,3i}∣≥2|A \cap \{3i-2, 3i-1, 3i\}| \ge 2, then A∩f(A)≠∅A \cap f(A) \ne \emptyset; or
(ii) 91,92,…,100∈A91, 92, \dots, 100 \in A, then A∩f(A)≠∅A \cap f(A) \ne \emptyset also holds.
In both cases, ff satisfies condition (2). If a subset BB of XX satisfies f(B)∪B=Xf(B) \cup B = X, then we have ∣B∩{3i−2,3i−1,3i}∣≥2|B \cap \{3i-2, 3i-1, 3i\}| \ge 2 for all 1≤i≤301 \le i \le 30, {91,92,…,98}⊆B\{91, 92, \dots, 98\} \subseteq B, and B∩{99,100}≠∅B \cap \{99, 100\} \ne \emptyset. Hence, ∣B∣≥69|B| \ge 69.

Next, we will show that, for any function ff satisfying the described conditions, there exists a subset B⊆XB \subseteq X with ∣B∣≤69|B| \le 69 such that f(B)∪B=Xf(B) \cup B = X.

Among all the subsets U⊆XU \subseteq X with U∩f(U)=∅U \cap f(U) = \emptyset, choose one such that ∣U∣|U| is maximal. If there are many U⊆XU \subseteq X with ∣U∣|U| being maximal, choose one such that ∣f(U)∣|f(U)| is maximal. The existence of UU is guaranteed by condition (1). Let V=f(U)V = f(U), W=X∖(U∪V)W = X \setminus (U \cup V). Note that U,V,WU, V, W are pairwise disjoint and X=U∪V∪WX = U \cup V \cup W. From condition (2), ∣U∣≤39|U| \le 39, ∣V∣≤39|V| \le 39, ∣W∣≥22|W| \ge 22.

We make the following assertions:
(i) f(w)∈Uf(w) \in U, for all w∈Ww \in W. Otherwise, let U′=U∪{w}U' = U \cup \{w\}, since f(U)=Vf(U) = V, f(w)∉Uf(w) \notin U, f(w)≠wf(w) \ne w, we have U′∩f(U′)=∅U' \cap f(U') = \emptyset. It is a contradiction to ∣U∣|U| being maximal.
(ii) f(w1)≠f(w2)f(w_1) \ne f(w_2) for all w1,w2∈Ww_1, w_2 \in W, w1≠w2w_1 \ne w_2. Otherwise, let u=f(w1)=f(w2)u = f(w_1) = f(w_2) then by condition (1), u∈Uu \in U. Let U′=(U∖{u})∪{w1,w2}U' = (U \setminus \{u\}) \cup \{w_1, w_2\}, since f(U′)⊆V∪{u}f(U') \subseteq V \cup \{u\}, U′∩(V∪{u})=∅U' \cap (V \cup \{u\}) = \emptyset, we have U′∩f(U′)=∅U' \cap f(U') = \emptyset. It is a contradiction to ∣U∣|U| being maximal.

Let W={w1,w2,…,wm}W = \{w_1, w_2, \dots, w_m\}, ui=f(wi)u_i = f(w_i), 1≤i≤m1 \le i \le m then by (i) and (ii), u1,u2,…,umu_1, u_2, \dots, u_m are distinct elements of UU.
(iii) f(ui)≠f(uj)f(u_i) \ne f(u_j) for all 1≤i<j≤m1 \le i < j \le m. Otherwise, let v=f(ui)=f(uj)∈Vv = f(u_i) = f(u_j) \in V, U′=(U∖{ui})∪{wi}U' = (U \setminus \{u_i\}) \cup \{w_i\}, then f(U′)=V∪{ui}f(U') = V \cup \{u_i\}, U′∩f(U′)=∅U' \cap f(U') = \emptyset. However, ∣f(U′)∣>∣f(U)∣|f(U')| > |f(U)|. It is a contradiction to ∣f(U)∣|f(U)| being maximal.

Therefore, f(u1),f(u2),…,f(um)f(u_1), f(u_2), \dots, f(u_m) are distinct elements of VV. In particular, ∣V∣≥∣W∣|V| \ge |W|. As ∣U∣≤39|U| \le 39, we have ∣V∣+∣W∣≥61|V| + |W| \ge 61 and ∣V∣≥31|V| \ge 31. Let B=U∪WB = U \cup W, then ∣B∣≤69|B| \le 69 and f(B)∪B⊇V∪B=Xf(B) \cup B \supseteq V \cup B = X. Overall, the desired smallest integer kk is 69. □\square

Want a route through all this instead of an archive? The track puts 2,604 problems in a working order, from Junior Challenge level to the IMO shortlist.

Source: MathNet, licensed CC-BY-4.0. Statement reproduced verbatim; metadata (topic, difficulty) added by this project.