is a non-empty subset of the set , satisfying:
(1) For any two numbers ( may not distinct), there exists , such that .
(2) For any two numbers ( may not distinct), there exists , , , such that , .
Find the largest possible value of .
Solution
Let be a non-empty subset of the set satisfying the following conditions:
1. For any two numbers (not necessarily distinct), there exists such that .
2. For any two numbers (not necessarily distinct), there exists , , , such that and .
We claim that the largest possible value of is .
To construct such a set , consider the set of positive integers less than or equal to 108 which have either 1 or 2 prime divisors among the set . By removing the elements 55 and 77 from and adding the elements 30, 60, 90, 42, and 84, we obtain a set of 79 elements that satisfies the given conditions.
To show that this is optimal, we proceed with the following lemmas and cases:
Lemma 1: There are at most 2 primes in which are greater than 7.
- Proof: Suppose primes were both in . Applying the second condition on them leads to a contradiction.
Lemma 2: .
- Proof: Applying the second condition on leads to a contradiction.
Using Lemmas 1 and 2, we can bound by 84. We now consider two main cases:
Case 1: There is no prime in .
- Among the pairs , at least one number in each pair must not be in . This reduces the upper bound from 84 to 77, which is less than 79.
Case 2: There is a prime in .
- We examine subcases where one of is not in . If , then either one of is in or . If , then either one of is in or . By similar logic, we can assume .
- We further consider subcases where are in but may or may not be in . Each subcase analysis shows that the upper bound is reduced to 79.
Thus, by exhausting all cases and subcases, we have shown that the maximum size of is 79.
The answer is .